Skip to Content

5 Beef Shank Alternatives for Your Recipes

Beef shank is great for hearty, flavorful dishes, but sometimes it’s just not an option. We’ve all been there, standing at the meat counter, rethinking dinner plans. 

The good news? There are plenty of substitutes that bring the same rich flavor and tender texture to the table.

From budget-friendly picks to cuts that cook up fast, there’s something for every recipe. Most of these options are easy to find, and some might already be in our fridge.

Swapping beef shank doesn’t mean sacrificing that slow-cooked, melt-in-your-mouth goodness we’re after—it’s just about knowing what works.

5 Quick Substitutes for Beef Shank

Here are five beef shank substitutes to try in your next recipe:

1 – Chuck Roast

Chuck roast works well as a beef shank substitute in many recipes.

We use the same weight of chuck roast as the amount of beef shank called for. It has a rich, beefy flavor and becomes tender with slow cooking.

It takes on sauces and seasonings beautifully, making it versatile for braises and stews. Chuck roast has more marbling, which adds extra juiciness to dishes.

It’s also easier to find and usually budget-friendly. Trim any excess fat if needed, and cook it low and slow to mimic the same melt-in-your-mouth texture.

This cut brings great results while keeping things simple.

2 – Beef Short Ribs

Beef short ribs are another cut that works well as a beef shank substitute. They’re flavorful and tender with slow cooking, just like beef shank.

We use the same weight of short ribs as we would for beef shank in a recipe. Be sure to trim off any excess fat before cooking.

Short ribs have a slightly different texture than beef shank, but they provide the same richness and depth of flavor to dishes. They also add a nice variety in terms of presentation and texture, with their bone-in structure.

Beef short ribs can be found in most grocery stores, usually in the meat section. For more ideas on using beef short ribs, check out our beef short ribs substitutes guide for tips and recipe inspiration.

3 – Oxtail

Oxtail is another flavorful and tender option to consider as a beef shank substitute. It has a rich, gelatinous texture when cooked low and slow, making it great for soups, stews, and braises.

We use the same weight of oxtail as we would for beef shank in a recipe. Be sure to trim off any excess fat before cooking, and cook it until it’s falling off the bone.

Oxtail can be found in most grocery stores, usually in the meat section.

4 – Lamb Shank

Lamb shank may not be as readily available as beef, but it’s a great alternative if you’re able to get your hands on some. It has a similar rich and tender texture when cooked low and slow, making it suitable for many beef shank recipes.

We use the same weight of lamb shank as we would for beef shank in a recipe. Be sure to trim off any excess fat before cooking. It also adds a unique flavor profile to dishes, bringing hints of gaminess and earthiness.

Lamb shank can typically be found at specialty meat markets or ordered from a butcher shop.

5 – Pork Shank

Pork shank, also known as pork hock, is a flavorful and economical alternative to beef shank. It has a similar texture and flavor when cooked low and slow, making it ideal for soups, stews, and braises.

We use the same weight of pork shank as we would for beef shank in a recipe. Be sure to trim off any excess fat before cooking. It can be found in most grocery stores or ordered from a butcher shop.

Don’t let the name “pork shank” scare you! Despite its off-putting appearance at first glance, this cut of meat is delicious and worth trying in your recipes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can chuck roast be used instead of beef shank?

Yes, chuck roast is a good substitute for beef shank. It’s a tender cut that works well for slow-cooking dishes, giving you the rich, beefy flavor you need.

How do beef short ribs compare to beef shank in cooking?

Beef short ribs are a great alternative to beef shank, offering a similar texture when braised. They are a bit fattier, adding a rich, tender quality to your dish.

Can oxtail replace beef shank in stews?

Oxtail is an excellent substitute for beef shank, especially in stews. It brings a rich, gelatinous texture due to its high collagen content, making it perfect for slow-cooked dishes.

How does lamb shank compare to beef shank?

Lamb shank is a great substitute, offering a similar texture and richness, though with a distinct lamb flavor. It’s perfect for those who prefer a slightly different twist on beef-based dishes.

Index