Skip to Content

7 Easy Brick Cheese Substitutes That Work Like a Charm

Brick cheese isn’t exactly a staple in most of our fridges, right? We’ve had those moments where a recipe calls for it, and we’re left scrambling for options.

Here’s the good news—you don’t actually need brick cheese to make it work. There are swaps that come super close in flavor and texture. Some are classics you already know, while others might surprise you.

We’ve got practical ideas you’ll appreciate, and chances are, you might already have these substitutes waiting in your fridge. No strange ingredients or extra grocery trips needed.

Whip up your dish with confidence because these replacements totally hold their own.

7 Easy Substitutes for Brick Cheese

Here are seven substitutes for brick cheese that will do the trick:

1 – Havarti Cheese

Did you know you can swap brick cheese with Havarti at a 1:1 ratio? It’s super creamy. It melts well and has that mild tang we all appreciate in cheese.

Havarti has a buttery texture. It’s softer than brick cheese but still works for most recipes. Grating it is a breeze, too.

Use Havarti in casseroles, sandwiches, or even pizza. The meltability is on point. It balances dishes without overpowering them.

If you need more options, check out this guide on Havarti cheese substitutes for extra inspiration.

2 – Monterey Jack Cheese

You’ll never believe how easy it is to use Monterey Jack instead of brick cheese. This cheese melts like a dream. It’s mild with a slightly sweet flavor that blends seamlessly into dishes. Use a 1:1 ratio for swaps.

It’s firm but smooth, making shredding fast and easy. Monterey Jack is great for nachos, tacos, and baked recipes. It adds creaminess without overpowering.

Need more swaps? Check out Monterey Jack cheese substitutes for more ideas.

3 – Muenster Cheese

Some recipes insist on Muenster, but guess what? Gouda works just as well. It’s semi-soft with a buttery, mild flavor. You can swap it 1:1 for Muenster in almost any dish.

Gouda melts beautifully too. It’s creamy and blends perfectly into sauces or casseroles. The texture is smooth, so slicing or shredding is a breeze.

If you’re curious about more options, check this guide on Muenster cheese substitutes for detailed alternatives.

4 – Cheddar Cheese

You’ll never believe how easy it is to swap cheddar with Colby cheese. It’s mild, slightly creamy, and melts just as well as cheddar. Use a 1:1 ratio for any recipe. It’s versatile and blends effortlessly into soups, sauces, or mac and cheese. Plus, the texture is ideal for slicing or shredding.

Colby gives a smoother, less sharp flavor compared to cheddar, making it great for those who prefer something milder. It works well in sandwiches, burgers, and even casseroles. The golden-orange color even mimics cheddar’s iconic look.

Want more alternatives? Check out this guide on cheddar cheese substitutes for additional ideas.

5 – Provolone Cheese

This one substitute will save your recipe with its mild taste and buttery texture. Provolone cheese works like a charm in both hot and cold dishes. Use it in a 1:1 ratio for mozzarella or other semi-soft cheeses.

Its soft melt makes it perfect for layering in lasagna or throwing on top of a pizza. It has just enough tang to keep things interesting, but not overpowering. Provolone slices also work great for sandwiches or wraps.

If you’re after a slightly sharper edge, aged provolone brings more flavor. Provolone is versatile, creamy, and blends well in nearly every cheesy recipe.

6 – Colby Cheese

If your recipe demands Colby cheese, you can swap it with Muenster cheese. It’s semi-soft with a buttery, slightly tangy flavor. Use it at a 1:1 ratio for the best results.

Muenster melts beautifully and adds creaminess to sauces or casseroles without overpowering them. The texture is smooth, making slicing or shredding a breeze.

If you’re curious about more options, check out this guide on Colby cheese substitutes for detailed alternatives.

7 – Fontina Cheese

Last but not least, Fontina is another fantastic substitute for brick cheese. It has a nutty, slightly sweet flavor that complements most recipes. Swap it in at a 1:1 ratio and enjoy its creamy texture and smooth melt.

Fontina shines in mac and cheese or any baked casserole, adding richness and creaminess without overpowering flavors. It also works well in cold dishes like sandwiches or salads.

If you want to get creative with more substitutes, check out this guide on Fontina cheese substitutes. You’ll be surprised by the variety of cheeses that can work as an alternative to brick cheese.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Havarti cheese a good alternative to brick cheese?

Yes, Havarti is soft and creamy, with a mild flavor that makes it a good match for brick cheese in many recipes.

Can I use Monterey Jack cheese instead of brick cheese?

Monterey Jack has a mild flavor and melts well, making it a great substitute for brick cheese in melted cheese dishes.

How does Muenster cheese compare to brick cheese?

Muenster cheese is slightly tangier and smoother, but it has a similar texture and mild flavor that makes it an effective replacement for brick cheese.

Can I use Cheddar cheese as a substitute for brick cheese?

Cheddar is sharper and firmer than brick cheese, but it can be used for a more robust flavor, especially in baked dishes.

Is Provolone cheese a good substitute for brick cheese?

Provolone has a mild, slightly smoky flavor and a firm texture, making it a good alternative for brick cheese in sandwiches or melts.

Can Colby cheese replace brick cheese in cheese platters?

Colby cheese is softer and milder, making it a suitable substitute for brick cheese in cheese platters and snacking.

How does Fontina cheese work as a substitute for brick cheese?

Fontina has a nutty and creamy texture, which works well in cooking, though it’s stronger in flavor than brick cheese.

Index