Skip to Content

5 Substitutes for Fennel Seeds: Elevate the Recipes

By: Author Andrew Gray

Posted on Last updated:

0 Comments

Out of fennel seeds? No worries!

It happens to the best of us – you’re in the middle of cooking something amazing and suddenly realize you’re missing an important part. 

Before you give up or rush to the store, check out these awesome replacements for fennel seeds that can save your meal and make it better. 

Each substitute has its special taste and touch, ensuring your food stays amazing. 

Whether making Italian sausage or spicing up a big stew, we’ve got the swaps that’ll let you forget you ever needed fennel seeds.

In short, you can elevate your recipes by substituting fennel seeds with star anise, cardamom, ground clove, dill seeds, or celery seeds. Each of these substitutes offers a unique flavor profile that can add an exciting twist to your dishes.

1 – Star Anise

Star anise is like the cool cousin of fennel seeds. It has that similar sweet, licorice-like flavor but with more punch.

brown leaves on black surface
Photo by Christina Rumpf on Unsplash

It’s perfect for when your dish needs that signature fennel vibe but you’re out of the seeds. This spice is a star in Asian cooking, adding depth to whatever you’re whipping up.

Using it as a substitute is pretty easy. Use one-star anise for every teaspoon of fennel seeds your recipe calls for.

Remember, it’s a bit stronger, so you don’t need as much. Throw it into your broths, stews, or any dish where fennel’s sweetness would shine.

Just make sure to fish it out before serving, as it’s not meant to be eaten whole.

2 – Cardamom

Cardamom is a superhero when you’re fresh out of fennel seeds. It’s unique, spicy-sweet vibe recalls the warmth of fennel but with its own twist.

Think of it as your recipe’s secret weapon for adding depth without going off track. 

Using cardamom is a breeze. If your dish is crying out for the complexity of fennel seeds, substitute them with ground cardamom at a one-to-one ratio.

This means if your recipe wants a teaspoon of fennel, go ahead and use a teaspoon of cardamom instead. Slide it into baked goods, curries, or even your morning coffee to bring a cozy warmth.

Just a heads up – cardamom’s flavor is bold to stand out in your dishes. Give it a try and watch it work its magic.

3 – Ground Cloves

Ground clove is your go-to when you want that warm, slightly sweet vibe in your dish, much like fennel seeds.

Why is it a great substitute? It adds a cozy touch to any recipe, making your food feel like a hug in a bowl. Plus, it’s a spice many of us already have chilling in our kitchen, so it’s super convenient.

When using ground clove instead of fennel seeds, start small. Use a quarter teaspoon of ground clove for every teaspoon of fennel seeds the recipe calls for.

Ground clove packs a punch; you can always add more if needed. It’s perfect for soups, marinades, and even baked goods where you want a hint of sweetness without overpowering the dish.

Just remember, a little goes a long way with this powerful spice.

4 – Dill Seeds

Dill seeds are the unsung heroes when finding a pinch hitter for fennel seeds. They’ve got that slightly sweet, grassy flavor that makes your dishes sing without missing a beat.

Why are they awesome? They bring a fresh, bright note to your food, adding a splash of sunshine.

Using dill seeds is super simple. Swap them in at a one-to-one ratio for fennel seeds. If your recipe needs a teaspoon of fennel, use a teaspoon of dill seeds instead.

They’re perfect for seafood dishes, dressings, or even bread. Dill seeds blend in smoothly, giving that whisper of sweet herbiness fennel seeds are famous for.

Just sprinkle them in and watch your dish come to life with a new but familiar flavor.

5 – Celery Seeds

Celery seeds are like the secret spice you never knew you needed to replace fennel seeds. They might be small, but boy, do they pack a flavor punch.

The beauty of celery seeds lies in their earthy, slightly bitter taste, which has a whisper of fennel’s sweetness. This makes them an excellent substitute when you’re in a pinch.

The trick to swapping in celery seeds is moderation. Use half a teaspoon of celery seeds for every full teaspoon of fennel seeds your recipe calls for.

This spice works wonders in soups, stews, and pickles. Because of their bold flavor, you want to start with a little and then taste as you go.

Add them to your dish and prepare for a subtle, intriguing twist that keeps your cooking exciting.