Skip to Content

5 Tasty Mustard Powder Substitutes in Your Cooking

Did you know mustard powder is a game-changer in the kitchen? It’s true.

This little spice can elevate a dish from “good” to “Can I have seconds?” in no time. We’ve all been there, halfway through cooking, only to find that mustard powder is missing from our pantry. Panic sets in.

No worries, though. We’ve got your back with five super swaps. Each substitute has been kitchen-tested by us, enduring a few cooking mishaps along the way (ever try making mustard-flavored ice cream? Not our proudest moment).

These alternatives will save your dinner and might just become your new favorites. Ready to dive in?

5 Easy Substitutes for Mustard Powder

The following substitutes can be used in equal amounts to the mustard powder called for in a recipe.

1 – Prepared Mustard

Prepared mustard, folks, is our first go-to swap. Think of it as mustard powder’s cooler cousin. It’s got the zing, without the need for a measuring spoon.

We’ve all been there, staring into the abyss of our fridge for answers. And there it is. The jar of prepared mustard.

Not only does it save your recipe, but it also adds a moist texture to your dishes. This is a key feature to notice. We learned this the hard way during a dry chicken disaster.

The beauty of this swap? It’s likely sitting in your fridge right now. We use it spoon for spoon in recipes, making life a tad easier.

Remember, for every teaspoon of mustard powder your dish calls for, simply use 1 teaspoon of prepared mustard.

2 – Dijon Mustard

Next up, we have Dijon mustard. You might think it’s just for fancy sandwiches. Not true. It works in a pinch as a mustard powder substitute. Our test kitchen has proven it.

We’ve tossed it in marinades and dressings. The flavor? Spot on. It’s sharper, so less is more. Found this out the hard way with an overly bold potato salad.

A little zing goes a long way. Use Dijon to keep your dishes lively. Keep the swap ratio simple. For every teaspoon of mustard powder, use ¾ teaspoon of Dijon mustard.

For those keen on further swaps, check out this article on Dijon mustard substitutes.

3 – Mustard Seeds

Next, mustard seeds step up to the plate. We’ve all seen these tiny guys, right? They’re the origin story of all things mustard.

Key feature? They pack flavor that’s both robust and smooth. This is essential. We’ve ground these seeds down for sauces and rubs. It works.

Our kitchen escapades taught us seed grinding skills. A coffee grinder turned spice mill. Our secret weapon.

The texture brings a unique edge to dishes, a bridge between crunchy and saucy. This point can’t be overlooked. We recommend using 1 crushed teaspoon of mustard seeds for every teaspoon of mustard powder needed.

For those curious about making the leap from seeds to powder, or finding more about mustard seeds and their uses, you’d likely enjoy reading this handy guide on mustard seeds substitutes.

4 – Horseradish

Horseradish comes into play with a distinct kick. This substitute brings in a spicy tang. It’s essential for those moments needing a bit of heat. We’ve learned this through trials in our own kitchen endeavors.

The key here is its raw, earthy tone. This sets horseradish apart. A dab added to recipes and there’s an unmistakable lift. Our own experiments, involving way too much horseradish in a stew once, proved its potency.

Moderation is your friend with this substitute. A little goes a long way. We recommend using ½ teaspoon of horseradish for every teaspoon of mustard powder needed in your dishes. If you’re curious about horseradish or need more options, you might find this article on horseradish substitutes helpful.

5 – Wasabi

Landing on wasabi as a mustard powder substitute might make you pause. We’ve tested it. It delivers a sharp, distinct flavor. A not-so-obvious choice, yet it works wonders for certain dishes. Especially where heat is welcomed.

Its unique zest adds an exciting layer. Key feature? It’s the surprise your dishes never knew they needed. We once used it in a dressing. The response? Unexpectedly rave reviews.

Moderation is crucial. Too much and you’re in for a shock. We found that out with a particularly fiery dip. Lesson learned. For every teaspoon of mustard powder needed, use just ½ teaspoon of wasabi.

If wasabi piques your interest, you might enjoy reading more about wasabi substitutes.