Skip to Content

5 Flavorful Alternatives to Pizza Sauce You’ll Love

Pizza is amazing, but sometimes we get tired of the same old tomato sauce routine. Last week, we decided to switch things up, and it led to some seriously tasty discoveries. The exciting part? There are so many easy alternatives that bring big flavors without overcomplicating the process.

We’ve tried everything from pesto to good ol’ garlic butter, and each one brought something unique to the table. One time, we used barbecue sauce on a whim, and it turned a regular pizza night into something unforgettable. Even something as simple as olive oil and herbs can reinvent your favorite slice.

If you’re like us, you want variety without the hassle of fancy ingredients. These swaps take basic pizza-making to the next level, and most of them are probably already in your pantry. Stick around, and we’ll show you how to shake up your pizza game with ease.

5 Easy Substitutes for Pizza Sauce

Here are our top five flavor-packed pizza sauce alternatives that are sure to delight your taste buds:

1 – Pesto

Basil is a staple in many pantries, and for good reason. When combined with pine nuts, garlic, Parmesan cheese, and olive oil, it makes the perfect pesto sauce. Spread it thinly on your pizza crust before adding toppings for an herbaceous twist.

If you don’t have fresh basil on hand, you can also use store-bought pesto or substitute with other herbs like parsley or cilantro.

For more ideas on using pesto as a pizza sauce alternative, check out our pesto substitutes guide for tips and recipe inspiration.

2 – Alfredo Sauce

Who says pizza can’t be fancy? A creamy alfredo sauce adds decadence and richness to your pie. Just make sure to use a light hand when spreading it on the crust, so the flavors don’t overpower your toppings

For an even more elevated experience, try making your own alfredo sauce at home with heavy cream, butter, garlic, and Parmesan cheese.

For more ideas on using alfredo sauce as a pizza sauce alternative, check out our alfredo substitutes guide for tips and recipe inspiration.

3 – Barbecue Sauce

Sweet and tangy barbecue sauce makes for an unexpected but delicious pizza topping. Spread it on the crust before adding toppings like chicken, onions, and peppers for a BBQ Chicken Pizza.

You can also mix things up by using different flavored barbecue sauces, like honey mustard or chipotle.

For more ideas on using barbecue sauce as a pizza sauce alternative, check out our barbecue sauce substitutes guide for tips and recipe inspiration.

4 – Garlic Butter

If you love garlic bread, then you’ll love this pizza sauce alternative. Spread a mixture of melted butter and minced garlic on your crust for a simple yet flavorful base.

For extra depth, mix in a pinch of sea salt, a dash of chili flakes for a mild kick, or even a spoonful of parmesan cheese to elevate the flavor.

You can also sprinkle some herbs like oregano, basil, or freshly chopped parsley on top for added aroma and taste. For a final touch, drizzle a bit of olive oil before baking to create a golden, crispy crust.

For more ideas on using garlic butter as a pizza sauce alternative, check out our garlic butter substitutes guide for tips and recipe inspiration.

5 – Olive Oil and Herbs

Sometimes, simpler is better. A light drizzle of olive oil with a sprinkle of dried herbs like oregano, basil, or thyme can add just the right amount of flavor to your pizza.

You can also experiment with a dash of rosemary or chili flakes for a little extra kick. It’s a great option for those who prefer a lighter and healthier alternative to traditional pizza sauces, without compromising on taste.

For even more depth of flavor, try infusing the olive oil with crushed garlic, minced onions, or even a few sprigs of fresh rosemary before spreading it on the crust.

If you’re feeling adventurous, you can mix in a splash of balsamic vinegar or a squeeze of fresh lemon juice to brighten the flavors even further. This simple yet versatile approach lets the quality of your toppings shine through while giving your pizza a unique, gourmet touch.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can pesto replace pizza sauce?

Pesto can be a delicious alternative, offering a fragrant, herby base that complements toppings well but lacks the tanginess of tomato sauce.

Is Alfredo sauce a good replacement for pizza sauce?

Alfredo sauce is a creamy alternative that works well with certain toppings like chicken or vegetables, though it’s richer than traditional pizza sauce.

Can I use barbecue sauce instead of pizza sauce?

Yes, barbecue sauce is a great substitute, especially for creating a smoky, sweet base that pairs well with meats like chicken or pork.

How can I make a simple olive oil and herb pizza sauce?

Combine olive oil with garlic, oregano, and basil for a light and fragrant sauce that lets your toppings shine without overpowering them.

Index