Skip to Content

6 Substitutes for Vanilla Extract: Enhance Baking Creations

Ever been all set to bake, only to realize you’re fresh out of vanilla extract? You open the cabinet, and bam, it’s not there.

Yeah, we’ve all been there. Good news, though! There are some awesome swaps you can use that might just be hanging out in your kitchen already.

This article will walk you through five simple substitutes that can save your dessert and maybe even take it to the next level. Whether you’re whipping up cookies, cakes, or any sweet treat in between, we’ve got your back.

Ready to play kitchen magician? Let’s get started!

1 – Vanilla Beans

Vanilla beans are the OG of vanilla flavor. They’re the real deal, straight from the vanilla plant, and pack a flavorful punch that can elevate any dessert.

Why go for the bean? It’s like choosing fresh fruit over canned; you get that rich, authentic taste. To use them, just slice the bean lengthwise and scrape out the tiny seeds inside.

Mix these seeds into your batter or dough. The general rule of thumb is one vanilla bean equals about three teaspoons of vanilla extract, but you can add more or less depending on your taste preference.

2 – Vanilla Bean Paste

If wielding a vanilla bean seems a bit too, well, vanilla for you, why not give vanilla bean paste a whirl? This stuff is like the convenience food of the vanilla world. It’s got all the intensity of flavor that you love from the beans, but it’s easier to use and measure out.

Think of it like the perfect middle ground between the whole bean and extract. Plus, it often comes with those tiny, delightful specks that can make your desserts look as gourmet as they taste. To substitute vanilla extract, use an equal amount of vanilla bean paste. It’s a one-to-one ratio, making your baking escapade as easy as pie.

3 – Flavored Extracts

Okay, so maybe vanilla’s off the table, but your cabinet is a treasure trove of other extracts. Almond, lemon, maple — these can be game changers in your baking. Why? They add a unique twist that’ll make people go, “Hmm, what’s that?” In a good way, of course.

Using them is a piece of cake. Just swap the vanilla extract with your chosen flavored extract. Start with a one-to-one ratio, but feel free to tweak it depending on how bold you want the flavor to be. Here’s a quick list:

  • Almond extract: Great for cookies and cakes. Gives a nutty warmth.
  • Lemon extract: Adds a refreshing zest, perfect for summer desserts.
  • Maple extract: Brings a cozy, rich sweetness. Ideal for fall treats.

Remember, these extracts can be potent, so it’s all about finding that sweet spot.

4 – Herbs and Spices

Ever thought about adding a dash of cinnamon or nutmeg instead of vanilla? These kitchen staples can spice up your desserts in a snap. They’re not just for pumpkin pie; they can add an interesting depth to all sorts of sweet treats.

Why reach for these when you’re out of vanilla? Because they add warmth, complexity, and a hint of cozy comfort that’s hard to beat. Plus, they’re super versatile. You can sprinkle cinnamon into your chocolate chip cookies or add a pinch of nutmeg to your banana bread for an extra flavor kick.

How to sub it in? Start with a quarter teaspoon of the spice for every teaspoon of vanilla extract you were supposed to use. Taste your batter and adjust if you think it needs a bit more pizzazz. It’s all about playing it by ear and your taste buds!

5 – Fruit Zest

When life gives you lemons (or oranges, or limes), use their zest as a vanilla substitute! Why? Because the zest adds a fresh, tangy kick that can really brighten up your sweets, making them taste like sunshine on a plate.

Zesting is super easy. Just grab your citrus fruit of choice, wash it, and use a zester or the fine side of a grater to get those colorful bits off the peel. But don’t go too deep – the white part underneath is bitter.

For using zest as a vanilla extract sub, a good rule of thumb is one tablespoon of zest for every teaspoon of vanilla extract you’re swapping out. This ratio keeps things zesty without overpowering your goodies. Give it a try the next time you’re in a pinch, or just feeling adventurous!

6 – Liquor

Ever think about adding a splash of liquor to your baking? Liquors like rum, bourbon, and brandy aren’t just for cocktails; they can also be a fantastic vanilla extract substitute. They bring a deep, complex flavor to the table that can really amp up your baking game.

Why liquor? Well, not only does it add a unique aroma and taste, but it also introduces an element of moistness to your goodies. And hey, it’s a great way to use up that bottle sitting in the back of your cupboard.

Using liquor as a substitute is easy-peasy. Just swap the vanilla extract with an equal amount of liquor. That means if your recipe calls for one teaspoon of vanilla, use one teaspoon of your chosen liquor instead.

It’s a one-for-one deal, making it a no-brainer swap. Just remember, a little goes a long way, so stick to the recipe’s suggested amount of vanilla extract for guidance.


And there you have it, folks! Who knew that your pantry and fridge were treasure troves full of vanilla extract substitutes?

To wrap things up, here’s the quick and dirty on each swap we’ve talked about—what it tastes like, and how much of it to use. Whether you’re in a pinch or just looking to shake things up, these substitutes have got your back.