Skip to Content

6 Montasio Cheese Substitutes: Amp Up Flavor

Montasio cheese is a game changer for flavor in many recipes. But what do we do when we can’t find it at our local store? We’ve got some amazing substitutions that’ll still bring that delicious tang to your dishes.

We’re talking about options that balance flavor and texture just right. Many of us have experienced the panic of missing that key ingredient. We’ve all been there.

So, let’s get to it. Here’s our list of the six best substitutes for Montasio cheese. Try these next time you’re in a pinch. Your tastebuds will thank you!

substitutes-for-Montasio-Cheese

6 Easy Substitutes for Montasio Cheese

For those who don’t know, Montasio is a cow’s milk cheese from the Friuli Venezia Giulia region of Italy. It has a nutty, buttery flavor and semi-hard texture.

But when you can’t get your hands on this delicious cheese, here are some substitutes that provide similar flavors and textures:

1 – Parmesan Cheese

Parmesan is a great Montasio substitute. It’s got that nutty, buttery flavor we love. The texture is just right too.

We use a 1:1 ratio for Parmesan to Montasio in recipes. So, if you’re out of Montasio, just grab some Parmesan.

It’s perfect for grating over pasta or adding to sauces. The flavor and texture are similar enough that you might not even notice the difference.

Check out this article on the best Parmesan cheese substitutes. You’ll find handy tips for other swaps too!

2 – Asiago Cheese

Why should we switch to Asiago cheese? Asiago offers a nutty and sweet flavor that’s incredibly similar to Montasio.

The texture? Spot on. For recipes, we use a 1:1 ratio—so if your dish calls for Montasio, just swap in equal parts Asiago.

We’ve made risottos with Asiago, and it melts perfectly. It’s a versatile option for grating over pasta or adding to sauces.

Curious about other asiago cheese substitutes? Check out this article on asiago cheese substitutes.

3 – Gruyère Cheese

In terms of texture, one close match for Montasio is gruyère cheese. Gruyère has a slightly more intense flavor than Montasio, but it still has that nutty profile we love.

For recipes, we recommend using a 1:1 ratio—so if you need a cup of Montasio, use a cup of gruyère.

It melts beautifully and adds delicious complexity to dishes like mac ‘n’ cheese or grilled cheese sandwiches.

Here are some gruyere cheese substitutes to check out for other recipe ideas.

4 – Pecorino Romano Cheese

For those who prefer a sharper flavor, Pecorino Romano is the way to go.

It’s similar to Parmesan but has a stronger taste. This cheese adds an extra tang and saltiness that makes it a great substitute for Montasio in dishes like pasta or pizza.

Use a 1:1 ratio when subbing in Pecorino Romano for Montasio. And check out this article on Pecorino Romano cheese substitutes for more ideas!

5 – Manchego Cheese

If you want a nutty, slightly sweet and tangy flavor, try using Manchego cheese as a substitute for Montasio.

The texture of manchego is semi-hard, making it perfect for melting over dishes or grating on top. For recipes that call for Montasio, use equal parts manchego instead.

It adds depth to dishes like quiche or grilled cheese sandwiches. Check out this article on manchego cheese substitutes for more ideas!

6 – Provolone Cheese

Last but not least, we have provolone cheese as a substitute for Montasio. It has a mild and creamy flavor similar to Montasio, and it melts beautifully.

Use a 1:1 ratio when subbing in provolone for Montasio—so if your recipe calls for one cup of Montasio, use one cup of provolone instead.

Try this in dishes like pasta or on top of pizza for added creaminess and flavor. Check out this article on provolone cheese substitutes for more ideas!