Skip to Content

7 Easy Stilton Cheese Substitutes: Jazz Up Meals

Stilton cheese isn’t in our fridge? No problem.

We all have those moments. You’re looking through the fridge, hoping to spot that crumbly, rich goodness of Stilton for your recipe, and it’s just not there.

Our kitchens have seen this too many times. Yet, we didn’t just stand there, staring into the cold void. We got creative. Think of this as our very own, “Oh no, not again” turned “Aha!” moment.

We’re about to lay down some cheese knowledge. The kind that saves dinners and impresses your friends. And trust us, we’ve had plenty of those “impress the friends” moments turn into “save the dinner” panics.

Ready? Set. Cheese substitute savvy, activate!

7 Easy Substitutes for Stilton Cheese

In terms of taste and texture, Stilton cheese is a unique one. Its crumbly yet creamy texture and strong flavor make it a beloved addition to any dish. There are plenty of substitutes that can jazz up your meals just as well.

SubstituteTasteTextureSuitable Dishes
GorgonzolaSharp, tangyCreamy, crumblySalads, pasta, sauces
RoquefortStrong, tangyCreamy, crumblyDressings, dips, cheese boards
Danish Blue CheeseMild, tangyCreamy, crumblySandwiches, burgers, salads
CambozolaMild, creamyCreamy, softCheese plates, crackers
Bleu d’AuvergneSharp, tangyCreamy, crumblySoups, sauces, dressings
Cashel BlueMild, nuttyCreamy, crumblyBreads, crackers, cheese plates
Shropshire BlueMild, tangyCreamy, crumblyBaked dishes, sauces, salads

1 – Gorgonzola Cheese

Gorgonzola cheese steps up to the plate. It’s got a bold flavor. We find it creamy and tangy. It loves to melt in your mouth. Perfect for creamy dishes.

We toss it into pastas and salads. A 1:1 swap does the trick. You won’t miss a beat in your cooking.

Got a recipe calling for that missing Stilton? Look no further. For those eager to get more ideas on swapping cheeses, this guide on alternative options for Gorgonzola cheese is a gold mine.

2 – Roquefort Cheese

Roquefort cheese takes the stage next. It’s like the cousin your dish didn’t know it needed. Its tangy vibes give any recipe that extra oomph. Swapping it in for Stilton works wonders, really. A 1:1 ratio makes it easy.

We’ve tossed this cheese into dishes that screamed for Stilton and barely noticed the switch. For all who need more on swapping these cheeses, this piece on Roquefort alternatives is stacked with ideas.

3 – Danish Blue Cheese

We’ve brought Danish Blue into the mix. It’s a friend in the cheese world. This cheese melts easily and brings a mild flavor to the table.

We say it’s a go-to for milder dishes. Swapping Danish Blue for Stilton works great on a 1:1 scale.

We’ve used it in recipes needing that Stilton touch and loved the outcome. If your dish could use a bit of cheese magic, Danish Blue has got you covered.

For those digging for more cheese swaps, find great blue cheese substitutes here.

4 – Cambozola Cheese

Cambozola cheese has become our go-to buddy. It easily enhances your dishes, making them cozy and cheesy. This creamy, blue cheese blend surprises us in the best way possible.

In our kitchens, we’ve switched from Stilton to Cambozola. A perfect 1:1 swap. And it’s magical. We’ve added it to our bakes and sauces, bringing a mellow yet rich vibe.

Looking to upgrade your cheese options? We’ve got key insights on Cambozola substitutes.

Discover easy cheese swaps in our guide to alternatives to Cambozola cheese, especially when you’re out of Stilton.

5 – Bleu d’Auvergne

We got Bleu d’Auvergne on the roster. It’s a chill cheese, not too sharp. It lays down smooth vibes in dishes. Melts easy, which we dig.

We swap it for Stilton at a cool 1:1. Works like charm in our salads and burgers.

Hooked on the idea of melting it over a hot steak. That combo seriously does wonders.

Found out the hard way it’s also a winner in a fancy mac and cheese. Our friends asked for seconds (and thirds!).

Discover its magic in your next meal.

6 – Cashel Blue Cheese

Cashel Blue steps in where Stilton steps out. It brings a gentle tang. Not too fierce. We like it in our recipes. It’s creamy, with just the right amount of kick.

A straight swap for Stilton, one for one, does the trick. We’ve thrown it into quiches. Made them taste good.

Some of us had it in a steak sauce. It was surprisingly tasty. Cashel Blue melts well. Works great in sauces and over veggies.

Give it a go in your next dish. You might find a new favorite.

7 – Shropshire Blue Cheese

Shropshire Blue cheese has made its mark in our hearts. It’s creamy and strikes with a mild yet noticeable tang.

We swap Stilton with Shropshire Blue, one for one, and it rocks. In our experience, it jazzes up a simple cheeseboard.

We’ve melted it into soups. The flavor blooms.

Shropshire Blue amps up a grilled cheese sandwich. You should try it and find its place in your next meal.