Skip to Content

6 Tasty Apple Butter Substitutes: Upgrade Your Recipes

We’ve all been there, flipping through a recipe, only to be stumped by the call for apple butter.

Maybe it’s not in the pantry, or maybe you’re just looking to shake things up a bit. Well, you’re in luck! We’ve got some yummy alternatives that will do the trick and then some.

From sweet to savory, these substitutes aren’t just stand-ins, they’re flavor enhancers. I remember trying out cashew butter on a whim and totally falling in love.

It’s all about finding what works best for us and our taste buds. Ready to experiment? Let’s find your new favorite ingredient!

6 Easy Substitutes for Apple Butter

While nothing can replace that velvety smooth apple butter texture, sometimes it’s just not a possibility. Whether you’re in the mood for something else or don’t have any apple butter on hand, here are some options to try:

1 – Applesauce

Have you ever thought: “What can I use instead of apple butter?” Well, applesauce is your new best friend. It’s got that sweet apple punch, minus the thick texture. Here’s the scoop: for every cup of apple butter, use a cup of applesauce.

It’s a perfect swap in any recipe. Just remember, applesauce lacks that velvety smoothness, so textures might differ a bit. I used applesauce in my grandma’s famous cake recipe, and she didn’t even notice the switch!

Pro Tip: If you’re searching for more inspired replacements, check out this guide on applesauce substitutes. It’s a game changer!

2 – Pumpkin Butter

Ever think of pumpkin butter as a swap for apple butter? Us too. It’s sweet, a bit spicy, and brings that fall vibe year-round. For every cup of apple butter, use a cup of pumpkin butter.

Unlike applesauce, it’s got a similar thick texture, so it’s a smoother match. We tried it on toast, and wow, it gives apple butter a run for its money.

Feeling adventurous? Mix it into your pancake batter. The spices add an awesome twist. Remember, pumpkin butter can be a tad sweeter, so you might want to dial back on sugar in your recipes.

3 – Pear Butter

Pear butter? Oh, you bet. It’s a super smooth, slightly sweet spread that goes great with breakfast and baked goods. Basically, you can swap it one-to-one with apple butter. That’s right – for every cup of apple butter, use a cup of pear butter.

It has that same luscious texture but with a bit more of a delicate flavor. Last winter, we spread pear butter on our waffles, and it was the perfect cozy morning treat. It’s like apple butter’s chill cousin – similar, but with its own thing going on. Perfect for switching things up in your recipes.

4 – Other Fruit Preserves

This one’s a gem. Ready for a twist on your classic apple butter? Let’s talk other fruit preserves. Think peach, cherry, or blackberry. They’re more than just jams; they bring fresh vibes to your favorite recipes.

For every cup of apple butter, you can use a cup of fruit preserves. Got some in the pantry? You’re all set. The texture’s similar, so it fits straight into your recipes without fuss.

A while back, we used cherry preserves on our morning toast. The sweetness was spot on and it added a zing we didn’t expect. Swap in different fruit preserves to find your new favorite!

5 – Apple Jam

Ready to give apple jam a shot? We were pretty stoked about how well it worked as a substitute. For every cup of apple butter, use a cup of apple jam. Super easy swap.

Apple jam has that sweet, tangy flavor we love. It’s a bit chunkier than apple butter but spreads well. On toast, it’s brilliant.

We tried it in a muffin recipe. That apple burst was a hit. So, if you’re out of apple butter, apple jam’s right there to save the day.

6 – Melted Butter

Melted Butter is like the smooth operator of apple butter substitutes. For every cup of apple butter, use half a cup of melted butter. We love it for its rich, creamy vibe.

Try it on pancakes or waffles. The buttery goodness adds a new layer of yum. In brownies or cakes, melted butter brings out deep flavors..

Last weekend, we swapped apple butter with melted butter in an old cookie recipe. The result? Soft, chewy cookies that disappeared in minutes.

Remember, you might need to adjust sugar in recipes, as butter isn’t sweet. Simple and delicious, give melted butter a shot!