Skip to Content

7 Substitutes for Beef Tallow: Zest Up Baking

Struggled with finding beef tallow for our recipes? Us too! We tried an endless number of greasy options before nailing down the best substitutes.

Ever had a lightbulb moment in the middle of baking? We did! One substitute saved our cookies from disaster. Another perked up our pastry crusts to perfection. We’re guessing you’re curious now.

Let’s talk about alternatives that won’t threaten your taste buds. Imagine upgrading your dishes without the drama of special trips to find beef tallow.

Ready to zest up your baking? Let’s dive right in!

7 Easy Substitutes for Beef Tallow

As in life, finding the best tallow substitute is a matter of taste. Some offer similar results while some completely change tastes radically.

1 – Butter

First, you gotta love butter for bringing richness to our bakes. We think it’s the OG tallow substitute. Butter melts beautifully and leaves a creamy, slightly sweet taste. It’s perfect for cookies and cakes but not so much if you’re aiming for deep frying.

Butter’s flavor shines in pastry crusts, making them golden and flaky. Crispy edges on cakes? Totally achievable with butter. If you’re cravin’ more substitutes, check this out: butter substitutes.

Remember, butter has a lower melting point than beef tallow, so keep an eye on the heat!

2 – Coconut Oil

The subtle, tropical vibe of coconut oil transforms our bakes. It’s less creamy than butter but adds a hint of sweetness. Brilliant for vegan recipes.

Coconut oil has a higher melting point than butter. This makes it fab for frying. For pastries, it creates a lovely, flaky texture.

We once swapped it in our cookie recipe. The cookies were crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and had a mild coconut flavor.

Curious about alternatives? Check substitutes for coconut oil.

3 – Vegetable Shortening

When we switched to vegetable shortening, the difference was instant. It’s all about that neutral flavor, not too sweet, not too overpowering.

Shortening creates a nice, flaky texture in pies. Cookies get crispy and a bit crumbly, with no greasy aftertaste. It’s more stable for frying too. Swapping it in, pastries almost reached bakery-level greatness.

Curious about other options? Check out these shortening substitutes. Shortening just works, plain and simple.

4 – Lard

The rich, savory taste of lard is tough to beat. It’s what makes our pastries unbelievably flaky and our fried foods oh-so-crispy. Lard has a higher smoke point than butter and coconut oil, perfect for frying without burning.

We noticed our pie crusts were next-level flakiness with lard. It gives that old-fashioned, homemade feel. Cookies baked with lard are rich and have a unique depth of flavor.

For more versatility, check out these lard substitutes. This will help if you’re out of lard but craving that signature richness.

5 – Olive Oil

One of our go-tos is olive oil. We love its sleek, rich taste.

Great for sautéing and drizzling over dishes. It adds a fruity, peppery note.

For pastries, it’s alright but makes them denser. Savory dishes shine with olive oil’s full-bodied flavor.

Cookies get a slight nutty hint, not super crispy. Different smoke point, use on medium heat. Superb in salad dressings.

We’ve found it amazing in our pasta recipes. More about olive oil substitutes.

Balance is key with this versatile oil.

6 – Duck Fat

The rich taste of duck fat is like nothing else. We’ve found it makes our pastries super flaky and our fried dishes extra crispy. It has a high smoke point, similar to lard, making it perfect for high-heat cooking.

Our roasted potatoes come out with a golden, crunchy exterior. Duck fat adds a mild, savory flavor to anything it touches. It’s a bit pricey, but definitely worth it. For a change, we switch it in to get that unique depth.

Curious about alternatives? Check out these duck fat substitutes.

7 – Bacon Grease

Last, we have bacon grease. It’s perfect for that smoky, savory kick. Bacon grease has a high smoke point and a lovely depth of flavor.

We love it for frying and roasting. Pastries get an extra crunch and unique taste. It’s got a delicious, salty vibe to it.

We’ve fried chicken in bacon grease, and the taste was mind-blowing. For more details, check out our bacon grease substitute options.

Bacon grease takes your dishes from good to amazing. It’s our go-to for adding richness.