Skip to Content

5 Creme de Menthe Substitutes: Add A Twist

We’ve all been there – hyped up to make a fancy cocktail, only to realize we’re out of crème de menthe. No need to put your mixology dreams on hold.

We’ve dug deep to find the best substitutes for that minty kick. Each option is something you probably already have, or can easily get. We’re talking everyday ingredients that won’t break the bank.

From mint syrup to peppermint schnapps, these replacements will keep your drinks fresh and tasty. The best part? You might discover a new favorite flavor twist! Let’s swap out the usual and keep our drinks interesting!

Creme de Menthe vs Peppermint Schnapps

Alright, folks, let’s dive into the ultimate minty showdown: Crème de Menthe vs Peppermint Schnapps. It’s like pitting Batman against Iron Man in a battle of boozy brilliance.

First things first, crème de menthe is the suave, sophisticated cousin—you know, the one with the fancy monocle and a taste for the finer things in life. It’s got that smooth, sweet mint flavour perfect for a Grasshopper cocktail or jazzing up your hot chocolate.

Peppermint schnapps, on the other hand, is the wild, fun-loving sibling who’s always the life of the party. It’s bolder, stronger, and packs a punch of peppermint that’ll wake up your taste buds faster than you can say “Fresh breath!”

This spirit is ideal for those rowdy nights involving shots, festive Christmas drinks, and adding a zing to your morning coffee (hey, we don’t judge).

Both can bring a minty freshness to your drinks, but they each have their own unique vibe. Crème de menthe whispers sweet nothings with its refined essence, while peppermint schnapps belts out classic rock tunes with its robust zing. So, why choose? Mix it up and keep those taste buds guessing!

5 Easy Substitutes for Creme de Menthe

Here are 5 easy substitutes for crème de menthe that will keep your drinks tasty and interesting:

1 – Mint Syrup

Mint syrup is our quick fix for a missing bottle of crème de menthe. It’s sweet and has a fresh mint flavor. We keep a bottle handy for easy mix-ins.

It’s less potent than peppermint schnapps but closer to traditional crème de menthe. Use it in cocktails or desserts for a subtle minty touch.

The consistency is thicker, like any syrup, so adjust the quantities. We’ve found it works wonders in mojitos and iced tea. Just a splash, and you’re good to go!

2 – Peppermint Extract

Peppermint extract is a potent option for a minty twist. It offers a strong, sharp peppermint flavor with a hint of sweetness. We often find that just a few drops can make a big difference in both taste and aroma.

The consistency is thin, unlike syrup or liqueur. This means you don’t need much – a little goes far. We use peppermint extract for festive drinks and desserts. It really shines in hot cocoa and brownies. When you crave boldness, this is your go-to.

However, remember to add slowly and taste as you go.

3 – Fresh Mint Leaves

The fresh mint leaves bring a subtle, crisp flavor to drinks and desserts. We love their clean, natural taste. Just muddle the leaves slightly to release the aroma.

The ratio? About six to eight leaves can substitute for a tablespoon of crème de menthe. Great in mojitos and punches, it adds a refreshing touch.

Unlike syrups or extracts, fresh mint leaves provide a lighter mint essence. We often use them in summer drinks. For more mint substitute ideas, check out these Clever Mint Substitutes.

4 – Peppermint Tea

Peppermint tea is an easy and delightful substitute for crème de menthe. Brew a strong cup and let it cool. The flavor profile is minty but mild, less intense than peppermint schnapps.

We usually steep two tea bags for an ultra-minty infusion. This gives drinks and desserts a refreshing twist. The natural mint essence is smooth.

It’s perfect for lighter cocktails. Works well in punches or iced teas. Mixed into desserts, it brightens without overpowering. We love it in mint chocolate chip ice cream. Peppermint tea balances sweetness with minty freshness.

5 – Other Flavored Liqueurs

Flavored liqueurs like Amaretto or Grand Marnier can substitute for crème de menthe. They bring unique tastes to the table. Amaretto offers a sweet, nutty profile.

Grand Marnier surprises with its citrus notes. These substitutes are versatile. Use a 1:1 ratio, just swap them in your recipes.

We’ve tried both with mixed results. Amaretto works in desserts, especially brownies. Grand Marnier shines in cocktails like margaritas. Choose based on the flavor you need. Different, but equally interesting!