Skip to Content

5 Substitutes for the Beloved Parmesan Cheese: Ultimate Cheat Sheet

Parmesan cheese, with its rich umami flavor and granular texture, is a staple in most kitchens — the magic dust that turns even the simplest of dishes into luxurious culinary masterpieces. But what if the grated goodness of Parmesan is off-limits?

We’re here with an exciting showcase of five fantastic substitutes that will take your taste buds on a delectable adventure. Whether you’re looking to diversify your cheese selection, catering to dietary restrictions, or just want to try something new, we’ve got you covered.

Join me as we tumble down the rabbit hole of savory delights. We’ll explore substitutions that mimic the tangy and savory punch of Parmesan, each with its unique flair. You don’t have to be an award-winning chef to appreciate the nuanced richness these cheeses bring to the table — just a passion for great food and a willingness to experiment.

5 Best Substitutes for Parmesan Cheese

1 – Pecorino Romano Cheese

Starting with a classic choice, Pecorino Romano is a robust, salty, and sheep’s milk cheese that’s been around for centuries. Many say it’s where the story of Parmesan began, offering an equally robust flavor and crumbly texture.

Pecorino Romano is the essence of salt, with a sharpness that cuts through any dish. It’s a hard cheese, so it grates beautifully and is perfect for melting into soups and pasta.

Substitute Ratio

Incorporate Pecorino Romano into your meals with delight. It likes to play in pastas, polentas, and risottos. The substitute ratio is 1 to 1 if you’re swapping it out for Parmesan in recipes, so go ahead and sprinkle with abandon.

2 – Grana Padano Cheese

Often referred to as “the cousin of Parmesan,” Grana Padano is less crumbly but equally delicious. With a milder flavor profile and beautiful pale yellow color, this cheese is a versatile substitute that offers a sophisticated charm.

Grana Padano’s slight sweetness and golden tones set it apart. It’s a creamier cheese, lending itself to finely grated processes. Use it for binding in dishes and enjoy the slightly nutty undertones.

Substitute Ratio

It’s a great all-around cheese — perfect on pastas, salads, and soups. In recipes, you’ll find it cozies up well with the ingredients at a 1 to 1 ratio with Parmesan.

3 – Asiago Cheese

Asiago is the cool kid on the block, with a multitude of forms that range from fresh and creamy to aged and crumbly. For Parmesan aficionados looking for something a little off the beaten path, Asiago may just be the answer.

The Asiago crowd-pleaser offers a smoother texture and a buttery finish. The aged version shares a nutty taste akin to a milder Parmesan — it’s like a silent nod to the original.

Substitute Ratio

From homemade pizzas to savory pastries, Asiago isn’t afraid to step into the spotlight. For cooking, match it up with Parmesan at a 1 to 1 ratio, and for garnish, shave it with enthusiasm.

4 – Manchego Cheese

A favorite from the heart of Spain, Manchego is typically made from sheep’s milk, lending it a unique profile. A good Manchego can hold its own against Parmesan with its distinctive tanginess.

Manchego’s bold flavor and grainy texture make it a contender for those who love a bit of complexity. It’s earthy, nutty, and a tad herbaceous. This cheese sings in spice-forward dishes.

Substitute Ratio

Manchego is a star performer in tapas, omelets, and stuffed pastries. For balance in recipes, use a slightly lighter hand; opt for a 1 to 1 ratio compared to Parmesan’s heft.

5 – Ricotta Salata

Ricotta Salata might surprise some as a Parmesan substitute, being a variation of the soft, moist Ricotta. However, once it’s salted and aged, it transforms into a firm piece of cheese with a crumbly texture and sharp taste.

Ricotta Salata adds a creamy saltiness and a unique twist to recipes. It’s on the milder side but still packs enough of a punch to make any dish stand out.

Substitute Ratio

Use it as a surprise substitute on your pastas and salads, or enhance your grilled vegetables with a sprinkle of Ricotta Salata. For recipes, mix it up at a 1 to 1 ratio, and for garnish, shave or crumble as desired.