Short Answer
Tubetti is the closest substitute for ditalini pasta, and small elbows, small shells, orzo or acini di pepe also work in soup, pasta salad and mac and cheese.
- Use the same weight of dry pasta that your recipe lists for ditalini.
- Taste a piece 2 to 3 minutes before the box time, since Barilla lists ditalini at 10 to 11 minutes and elbows at 7 to 8.
- In soup, add the elbows about 3 minutes after the point where ditalini would go in.
Ditalini means "little thimbles" in Italian, and any of these pasta swaps has to match that small size: a short hollow tube that sits on a spoon next to a bean or a cube of carrot. A swap can carry a soup or a salad once you allow for the one thing that changes from shape to shape, the cooking time, so each one needs its own check in the pot.
1 What Does Ditalini Do in a Recipe?
The hollow center and the short length are what make ditalini work on a spoon. The center fills with broth or dressing, so each piece carries some of the liquid it sits in, and the length lets you lift pasta, beans and chopped vegetables in one scoop.
A substitute has to be small enough for that spoonful, which is why long strands and large tubes fall short.
Three kinds of dishes call for it, and each asks something different of a stand-in:
- Pasta e fagioli and minestrone cook the pasta right in the broth, where it keeps absorbing liquid until the pot comes off the heat.
- Pasta salad takes it boiled, drained and cooled, and some brands sell it as salad macaroni.
- Mac and cheese uses it when you want a smaller bite than elbow macaroni gives.
Some boxes say rigati, the Italian word for ridged. The ridges give a sauce a little more to cling to, so a smooth swap grips slightly less, which you will notice most in a thick tomato sauce.
2 Best Substitutes for Ditalini Pasta
Use the same weight of dry pasta that your recipe lists for ditalini, because a cup of orzo, elbows or acini di pepe does not hold the same amount of pasta.
An Oklahoma State University Extension recipe counts 2 cups of dry ditalini as 8 ounces, so if your recipe is written in cups, plan on about 4 ounces for each cup. The times for each swap come from Barilla's US labels, or DeLallo's for acini di pepe, and another brand can differ by a minute or two.
| Substitute | Amount for ditalini | Cook time (ditalini: 10 to 11 minutes on the box) | Best for | What changes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tubetti or tubettini | Same weight | No maker label found; cook like ditalini and taste 2 minutes early | Any ditalini recipe | A short hollow tube, cut a little longer or shorter by each brand |
| Small elbow macaroni | Same weight | 7 to 8 minutes | Soup, pasta salad, mac and cheese | Curved tube that finishes 3 minutes sooner |
| Small shells | Same weight | 8 to 9 minutes (Barilla medium shells) | Pasta salad, mac and cheese, brothy soup | Cups dressing and beans in the curl and finishes 2 minutes sooner |
| Orzo | Same weight | 9 to 10 minutes | Brothy soup, tomato one-pot dishes | Rice-shaped with no hollow, finishes 1 minute sooner |
| Acini di pepe | Same weight | 6 to 7 minutes in simmering broth (DeLallo guide) | Broth soups, salads with a light oil dressing | Tiny beads that get lost in a chunky sauce |
| Broken spaghetti | Same weight | 9 to 10 minutes | Pasta e fagioli, minestrone | Uneven lengths, finishes 1 minute sooner |
| Gluten-free elbows | Same weight | 7 to 8 minutes | Gluten-free soup and pasta salad | Corn and rice pasta that finishes 3 minutes sooner |
Every substitute except tubetti finishes sooner than ditalini's 10 to 11 minutes, so you start tasting earlier by that much:
- Acini di pepe: 4 minutes.
- Elbows and gluten-free elbows: 3 minutes.
- Small shells: 2 minutes.
- Orzo and broken spaghetti: 1 minute.
3 How Do You Use Each Ditalini Substitute?
1. Tubetti and Tubettini
Tubetti is the nearest match, a short hollow tube that goes into any ditalini recipe at the same weight. Tubettini is the smaller cut, and brands cut both a little longer or shorter than ditalini, so look at the pieces in the box before you commit.
Cook it as you would ditalini and taste a piece 2 minutes early, since the box time varies by brand. In a bean soup the tube fills with broth exactly as ditalini does, so you change the dish less with this swap than with any other.
2. Small Elbow Macaroni
Elbows are the easiest swap to find, and Barilla's box lists 7 to 8 minutes against ditalini's 10 to 11. In soup, that 3-minute gap decides the swap.
Tip
Add the elbows about 3 minutes after the point where ditalini would go in, or they go soft while the rest of the pot catches up.
Elbows can also cook straight in the sauce, which saves a pot, as in a macaroni dinner with ground beef made in the Instant Pot.
In boiling water, give elbows a large pot of salted water and stir during the first minute so the pieces do not clump.
3. Small Shells
Pick the smallest shells on the shelf. Barilla's medium shells list 8 to 9 minutes, 2 minutes under ditalini, and the curled opening holds dressing, beans and chopped vegetables the way ditalini's hollow does.
Small shells cup corn, beans and diced vegetables the way a ditalini tube does, so they suit a bacon and bell pepper pasta salad with corn and black beans. Small shells cook a minute or two sooner than medium ones, so taste early.
4. Orzo
Orzo is a rice-shaped pasta with no hollow center, so a piece carries less broth than a tube does, but it spreads evenly through a spoonful of soup. Barilla's box lists 9 to 10 minutes, one minute under ditalini, so you barely change your soup's timing.
Orzo keeps swelling in hot liquid, which thickens a pot as it sits. Dry orzo can simmer straight in tomato and broth, and its starch gives the pot a creamy body, as in a creamy tomato orzo with spinach.
5. Acini Di Pepe
Acini di pepe means "peppercorns" in Italian, and the pasta is a tiny bead of durum semolina. DeLallo's guide cooks it in simmering broth for 6 to 7 minutes, the shortest time here, so it goes into a brothy soup for its last 6 to 7 minutes only.
Tip
The beads get lost in a typical pasta sauce, and a creamy macaroni-salad dressing weighs them down, so dress your acini di pepe salad lightly with olive oil.
6. Broken Spaghetti
Oklahoma State University Extension's pasta e fagioli calls for 2 cups of ditalini or broken pasta such as fettuccine, 8 ounces either way, so snapped long pasta is an accepted swap in that soup. Break dry spaghetti into pieces about as long as a ditalini tube, then cook for Barilla's 9 to 10 minutes, a minute under ditalini.
The pieces come out in uneven lengths, so keep this one for soups, where the broth hides the difference.
7. Gluten-Free Elbows
Barilla's gluten-free elbows, made from corn and rice, list 7 to 8 minutes, the same as its wheat elbows and 3 minutes under ditalini. Taste early, and add them to soup late.
If you are cooking for someone with celiac disease, check the box for a certified gluten-free label.
4 Which Ditalini Substitute Works Best in Soup?
In soup, pick the swap whose box time sits closest to ditalini's 10 to 11 minutes, because your soup's timing was written around that number.
Small Elbows
Easy to find, and the curved tube still holds a spoonful of broth.
Done in 7 to 8 minutes, so they go in about 3 minutes after ditalini would.
Orzo
Within 1 minute of ditalini's time (9 to 10 minutes), so the recipe's timing barely moves.
No hollow center, and it keeps swelling, so leftover soup is thick the next day.
Whichever pasta you choose goes in late, because small pasta keeps absorbing broth, and DeLallo advises adding ditalini toward the end of a soup's cooking for that reason.
Pasta E Fagioli and Minestrone
Oklahoma State University Extension's pasta e fagioli adds the pasta to boiling broth and tomatoes, cooks it at a strong simmer until al dente, and only then stirs in the beans for 2 minutes. The same pasta-in-the-pot method carries over to minestrone, where you can use tubetti, small shells or broken spaghetti at the same weight, and a pasta that finishes sooner than ditalini goes in nearer the end.
Italian Wedding Soup
Italian wedding soup is a good home for acini di pepe: DeLallo adds it to simmering broth for 6 to 7 minutes, then serves. Orzo works in the same pot but needs 9 to 10 minutes, so you add it earlier.
5 Which Ditalini Substitute Works in Pasta Salad and Mac and Cheese?
Pasta Salad
A salad is where cook time matters least, because you drain and cool the pasta before it meets the dressing. Cook it to al dente, since it softens a little more as it sits in the dressing.
A macaroni salad with tuna is built on elbows, and ditalini, tubetti and small shells hold the same dressing at the same weight.
- Acini di pepe suits a salad dressed only with olive oil.
- Orzo suits a salad with chopped vegetables and a vinaigrette.
Mac and Cheese
Elbows are the standard mac and cheese pasta, and DeLallo suggests ditalini instead of macaroni for a smaller bite, so the swap runs in both directions. Small shells catch cheese sauce in the curl, so each piece comes out coated inside and out.
A mac and cheese written for 8 ounces of dry elbows or shells takes ditalini at the same 8 ounces, whichever of the mac and cheese variations you start from.
6 Which Pasta Swaps Do Not Work for Ditalini?
- Whole spaghetti or linguine tangles around the spoon and drips back into the bowl, so snap it into short pieces first.
- Large tubes such as rigatoni or ziti take a whole spoonful for one piece, which leaves no room for beans and vegetables in a soup.
- Acini di pepe in a chunky sauce disappears into the meat or tomatoes, and DeLallo says the beads get lost in a typical pasta sauce.
7 How Do You Cook the Swap and Store the Leftovers?
Ditalini and its substitutes cook two ways. In water, bring a large pot of salted water to a rolling boil, add the pasta, stir once and drain at al dente.
In soup, simmer the pasta in the broth near the end of cooking and turn off the heat when it is al dente, because the pasta absorbs some of the broth, as DeLallo describes.
Warning
Refrigerate pasta salad, soup and mac and cheese within 2 hours of cooking, or within 1 hour when the room is above 90°F, and eat leftovers within 3 to 4 days.
Pasta left in soup keeps absorbing liquid, so leftover soup thickens overnight, and a splash of broth or water loosens it when you reheat. FSIS says to reheat leftovers to 165°F, which you can confirm with a thermometer in the center of the pot.
Frequently Asked Questions
Ditalini is a short hollow tube that fits on a spoon, so it works in soups and salads. Tubetti, small elbows, small shells, orzo and acini di pepe all replace it at the same weight, and the only change is cooking time.
Yes. Barilla lists orzo at 9 to 10 minutes against 10 to 11 for ditalini, so the timing barely changes. Orzo has no hollow center and keeps swelling in the broth, so leftover soup gets thick.
Small shells and elbows hold dressing well. Shells trap bits of tomato and cucumber in their curl, and elbows suit creamy dressings such as the one on a tuna macaroni salad.
Yes. Tubettini is the smaller cut of the same short tube, and it goes in at the same weight. Cook it as you would ditalini and taste a piece 2 minutes early, since brands differ.
Yes, if you add it later. Barilla's elbows cook in 7 to 8 minutes against 10 to 11 for ditalini, so put them in about 3 minutes after the point where ditalini would go in.
Creamy Tomato Macaroni & Cheese
Equipment
- Large pot
- Wooden spoon or spatula
- Measuring cups and spoons
Ingredients
- 2 tablespoons olive oil
- 1 onion chopped
- 3 cloves garlic minced
- 1 teaspoon dried oregano
- 1 teaspoon dried basil
- 1 can 28 ounces crushed tomatoes
- 3 cups chicken or vegetable broth
- 1 cup water
- 1 cup elbow pasta
- Pinch of red pepper flakes optional
- Salt and pepper to taste
Instructions
- In a large pot, heat olive oil over medium heat.
- Add chopped onion and cook for 5 minutes until softened.
- Stir in minced garlic, dried oregano, dried basil, and red pepper flakes (if using). Cook for 1 minute.
- Pour in crushed tomatoes, chicken or vegetable broth, and water. Bring to a boil.
- Reduce heat to low and let the soup simmer for 15 minutes.
- Season with salt and pepper to taste.
- Add elbow pasta and cook for 7-8 minutes, or until al dente. Stir occasionally to prevent sticking.
- Serve hot, garnished with grated Parmesan cheese and fresh basil (if desired).
Nutrition
Sources
- Barilla US, Ditalini (cooks in 10 to 11 minutes)
- Barilla US, Elbows (7 to 8 minutes)
- Barilla US, Medium Shells (8 to 9 minutes)
- Barilla US, Orzo (9 to 10 minutes)
- Barilla US, Spaghetti (9 to 10 minutes)
- Barilla US, Gluten Free Elbows (7 to 8 minutes, corn and rice)
- DeLallo, All About Acini Di Pepe (6 to 7 minutes in soup)
- DeLallo, All About Ditalini Pasta (name, soups, cooking in broth)
- Oklahoma State University Extension, Pasta e Fagioli (2 cups of ditalini is 8 ounces)
- USDA FSIS, Leftovers and Food Safety

Andrew Gray is a seasoned food writer and blogger with a wealth of experience in the restaurant and catering industries. With a passion for all things delicious, Andrew has honed his culinary expertise through his work as a personal chef and caterer.
His love for food led him to venture into food writing, where he has contributed to various online publications, sharing his knowledge and insights on the culinary world. As the proud owner of CooksCrafter.com, Andrew covers a wide range of topics, including recipes, restaurant reviews, product recommendations, and culinary tips.
Through his website, he aims to inspire and educate fellow food enthusiasts, offering a comprehensive resource for all things food-related.









