Skip to Content

5 Savory Substitutes for Edam Cheese

When it comes to crafting the perfect plate, cheese is often the not-so-secret ingredient that holds it all together. For those of us who indulge in the creamy nuances of Edam cheese, there’s an unmistakable richness that we loyally include in many of our dishes.

But what happens when dietary restrictions or a simple desire to experiment push us toward more versatile options?

To the cheese aficionado who loves to explore the world of flavors and textures, I’m here to unveil five stellar substitutes for Edam Cheese that are bound to exhilarate your taste buds and impress your dinner guests.

So without further ado, let’s dive into the alternatives.

5 Savory Substitutes for Edam Cheese

1 – Gouda Cheese

Imagine a perfect world where every bite of cheese comes with a satisfying, delectable creaminess. Welcome to the realm of Gouda cheese, a Dutch classic known for its soft texture and subtle sweet taste. Whether melted over a warm dish or sliced on a fresh baguette, Gouda’s versatility knows no bounds.

Gouda Cheese, with its mild and slightly tangy notes, is a majestic stand-in for Edam. It boasts a similar smooth texture yet with a slightly more robust flavor profile that adds depth to your dishes.

When substituting Gouda for Edam, consider about a 1-to-1 ratio, or slightly more, depending on the recipe’s intensity. Use it in a creamy soup or as the star in your grilled cheese for a comforting twist.

It pairs brilliantly with sandwiches, quiches, and savory tarts, offering that perfect melt when you want to savor the notes from any dish that’s heated up.

2 – Swiss Cheese (Emmental)

For those who crave a cheese that’s both nutty and full-flavored, Swiss is the natural next step. Also known as Emmental, its iconic appearance, marked by its large holes, is matched only by its iconic taste.

Swiss Cheese impresses with a nutty, yet somewhat buttery taste and is ideal for those classic sandwiches like the Reuben or Croque Monsieur.

Use Swiss Cheese as a one-to-one substitute for Edam. Whether you’re baking a classic macaroni and cheese or looking to perfect a Croque Madame, Swiss cheese will crown your dish with its unbeatable melty goodness and depth of flavor.

Its strength in melting makes it an ideal choice for a gratin, where you need that top layer to brown beautifully and maintain a delightful texture.

3 – Havarti Cheese

Havarti is a semi-soft cheese that falls on the milder side of the spectrum when it comes to cheeses, yet it doesn’t shy away from being the star of the show with its creaminess and a hint of tang.

Havarti’s buttery texture and mild acidity make it a preferred choice when a complex layer of mouthfeel is required, especially if you’re looking for a cheesier oomph in a cheese plate or a cheese sauce.

Since Havarti is creamier than Edam, use it as a slightly milder substitute, generally at a 1-to-1 ratio. It’s fantastic for creamy vegetable soups or even in an ooey-gooey meatball sandwich.

Try it in your next homemade pizza, and watch how it melts beautifully over each slice, adding a Danish touch to an Italian classic.

4 – Provolone Cheese

If you’re after a cheese with enough backbone to stand up to bold flavors, Provolone should be at the top of your list. This Italian cheese brings a smokiness that adds layers of intrigue to dishes.

With its characteristic pungent flavor, Provolone is an excellent choice when you need cheese to shine through in hearty dishes without being too overpowering.

In most dishes, you can swap Provolone for Edam in a 1-to-1 ratio. From casseroles to homemade burgers, Provolone gives you that robust kick that takes a meal from good to great.

It’s a standout performer in grilled paninis or portabello mushroom burgers, where its rich flavor can dance with the other ingredients.

5 – Muenster Cheese

Like a silent superhero, Muenster cheese doesn’t make much ado about its abilities until it’s time to melt. Then, it reveals its true power—a luscious creaminess that’s unparalleled, making it a champion in the cheese world.

Muenster offers a gentle, buttery taste with a mild tang that makes it ideal for those seeking a balanced flavor that isn’t too overpowering.

Because it’s relatively mild, use Muenster in a 1-to-1 ratio in recipes that call for Edam. Muenster’s exceptional melting capabilities are perfect for dishes like stuffed mushrooms or a complete melt takeover in a bowl of French onion soup.

Its smooth, creamy texture shines in Mexican dishes, giving a melt-in-your-mouth experience to classics like nachos or quesadillas.

Bringing It All Together

When it’s time to redefine your culinary comfort zone, these Edam alternatives swoop in to save the meal (and the day). Whether you’re crafting a homemade mac and cheese or experimenting with an inventive cheese fondue, each of these cheeses can flawlessly fill the shoes of Edam, offering a burst of flavor unique to their own profiles.

In the end, it’s not about the cheese you can’t use; it’s about the cheese you haven’t met yet. And there’s no better time than now to make some new cheesy acquaintances.