Skip to Content

5 Tasty Substitutes for Goat Cheese to Consider

By: Author Andrew Gray

Posted on Last updated:

0 Comments

If you’re a card-carrying member of the foodie club, you know that goat cheese reigns as king in the world of fromage. This tangy delight is renowned for its versatility, making it a highlight in countless recipes, from creamy pasta to zesty salads.

However, what if I told you that there’s a world beyond goat cheese that’s just as indulgent and—dare I say—even more suited to certain dishes? Join me as I swap goat cheese for some seriously delectable substitutes that might just become your new kitchen favorites.

substitutes-for-goat-cheese Save for Later!

Key Takeaways:

  • Goat cheese is a versatile, tangy delight that reigns supreme in the world of fromage.
  • Feta, cream cheese, cottage cheese, ricotta, and labneh are all fantastic substitutes for goat cheese in various dishes.
  • Each alternative brings its own unique flavor and texture to recipes, providing a pleasant deviation from traditional goat cheese.
  • Keep the ratio of substitute to goat cheese 1:1 for best results.

5 Tasty Substitutes for Goat Cheese

So, what are these elusive cheese alternatives, you may ask? Well, I’m glad you asked! Here are my top five favorite substitutes for goat cheese that will surely have you rethinking your dairy choices.

1 – Feta Cheese

Feta cheese, the staple of Mediterranean cuisine, is a brined curd cheese traditionally made from sheep or goat’s milk. Its piquant flavor and crumbly texture make it an ideal replacement for goat cheese in many recipes, especially salads, wraps, and pastries.

To make the switch, use a 1:1 ratio of feta to goat cheese and enjoy the punchy notes that complement dishes perfectly.

2 – Cream Cheese

Nothing beats the creamy smoothness of cream cheese, which serves as an excellent alternative to goat cheese in spreads, dips, and desserts. With its mild, slightly tangy flavor, cream cheese pairs beautifully with both sweet and savory dishes, providing a luxurious texture that never disappoints.

When using it as a goat cheese substitute, combine it in equal parts, and relish the rich results.

3 – Cottage Cheese

Cottage cheese, often overlooked, brings a different texture to the table. Its curd-like consistency provides a refreshing take in sandwiches, wraps, pizzas, and even as a topping on baked dishes. While the tang of goat cheese is missing, cottage cheese’s neutral flavor is the canvas for bolder ingredients to shine through.

To replace goat cheese with cottage cheese, mix it in a 1:1 ratio and enjoy the lighter, fresher taste it imparts.

4 – Ricotta Cheese

Ricotta, an Italian whey cheese, might surprise you with its versatility in both savory and sweet dishes. Its smooth, creamy texture makes it a direct swap for goat cheese in recipes like stuffed pasta, breakfast toast, and cheesecakes.

Simply replace goat cheese with ricotta at a 1:1 ratio and savor the velvety goodness it brings to the table.

5 – Labneh Cheese

Labneh, the strained yogurt cheese of Middle Eastern cuisine, packs a zingy punch that closely rivals goat cheese. With a texture that lies between creamy and crumbly, labneh is a fantastic alternative for dips, sandwiches, and even as a stand-in for goat cheese in pasta dishes.

To switch to labneh, use an equal amount and be ready to be pleasantly surprised by its versatility.

Each of these five contenders brings a unique twist to the dishes normally graced by goat cheese, and I’ll wager you might just prefer one of these choices when they’re nestled on your next cracker or gracefully garnishing a salad.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes goat cheese unique, and how can I replicate its tangy flavor?

Goat cheese has a tangy, creamy texture with a slightly earthy taste. Feta cheese comes closest in terms of tang, while cream cheese provides similar spreadability without the same sharpness.

Is feta a good substitute for goat cheese in salads?

Yes, feta works well in salads as it offers a similar crumbly texture and tangy taste. It’s slightly saltier than goat cheese, so you may want to adjust seasoning accordingly.

Can I use ricotta instead of goat cheese in pasta dishes?

Ricotta is a great alternative for pasta dishes, offering a creamy texture. However, it’s milder in flavor, so you might want to mix in a little lemon juice or salt to enhance the taste.

Which goat cheese substitute melts best?

Cream cheese and labneh melt well and provide a smooth, rich consistency. Feta and cottage cheese don’t melt as easily but still add a creamy texture when heated.

What’s the best goat cheese alternative for a cheese board?

Labneh is a great alternative for cheese boards, as it has a thick, creamy texture similar to soft goat cheese. Pair it with honey or nuts for a similar sweet-and-savory combination.