Skip to Content

6 Easy Substitutes for Lancashire Cheese: Flavor It Up

You ever just crave something super yummy, but feel like you’ve tried everything? We’ve all been there.

You know what’s a game-changer? Discovering new foods or substitutes that shake up our routine!

Today, we’re talking Lancashire cheese substitutes. Sure, the real deal is delicious, but sometimes it’s out of stock, too pricey, or you just want to try something different.

Let’s chat about six easy alternatives that can flavor up our favorite dishes. These substitutes are perfect for every kind of cheese lover. Buckle up, because your taste buds are in for a treat!

6 Easy Substitutes for Lancashire Cheese

For those who are unfamiliar, Lancashire cheese is an English cheese known for its crumbly texture and tangy taste. It’s traditionally made with cow’s milk and goes through a ripening process that can last from six weeks to a year.

But if you can’t get your hands on this delicious cheese, here are some easy substitutes that will satisfy your cravings:

SubstituteTasteTextureRatioSuitable Dishes
Cheshire CheeseMild, slightly nuttyCrumbly1:1Cheese boards, salads, sandwiches
Wensleydale CheeseCreamy, slightly sweetSmooth, creamy1:1Desserts, fruit pies, cheese plates
Caerphilly CheeseTangy, slightly saltyFirm, crumbly1:1Soups, stews, casseroles
Sage Derby CheeseHerbal, slightly nuttyFirm, smooth1:1Cheese plates, sandwiches, quiches
Aged Cheddar CheeseSharp, tangyFirm, crumbly1:1Macaroni and cheese, cheese sauces, burgers
Cream CheeseMild, slightly tangySoft, creamy1:1Cheesecakes, dips, frostings

1 – Cheshire Cheese

Alright, let’s talk Cheshire cheese. This one’s got a smooth, creamy vibe with a nice tang. It’s perfect for those who love a bit of sharpness in their cheese.

We tested it, and it melted like a dream, which makes it great for cooking. Toss it in your favorite dishes, and you’ll get a delightful surprise.

The taste is close to Lancashire but creamier. Use it in a 1:1 ratio for most recipes. Whether you’re sprinkling it on a salad or melting it in a grilled cheese, Cheshire’s your go-to.

2 – Wensleydale Cheese

We tried Wensleydale and loved its crumbly, slightly sweet texture. Think of a milder taste, almost like a creamy delight with a hint of honey.

Perfect for salads and cheese boards. Toss it in your mashed potatoes, and it melts beautifully. The texture is spot on for those who want a less tangy option than Lancashire.

For swaps, you can use it as a 1:1 substitute in most recipes. Just sprinkle it on and enjoy. No fuss, just simple and tasty.

3 – Caerphilly Cheese

We gave Caerphilly cheese a try and were pleasantly surprised. It’s got that crumbly texture we love but comes with a mild, slightly tangy flavor. Think of it as a mellower cousin to Lancashire.

It holds well in recipes and can be crumbled or sliced easily. This cheese shines in cold dishes like salads due to its light and fresh taste. We especially enjoyed it in a sandwich—it added the right amount of zest.

When substituting, use it in a 1:1 ratio. Whether melted or fresh, Caerphilly is a solid pick.

4 – Sage Derby Cheese

Ok, let’s talk about Sage Derby cheese. This one is speckled with sage, which gives it a cool green look and a unique flavor.

We love its semi-hard texture. It’s got a mild, herby taste that’s super refreshing. Think of it as cheese that brings a garden to your taste buds.

Perfect for pairing with crackers or adding to a salad. We’ve used it with a 1:1 substitution ratio in recipes that call for Lancashire. It melts well, making it a solid choice for grilled cheese sandwiches or baked dishes.

5 – Aged Cheddar Cheese

Alright, let’s talk about aged cheddar. This cheese has a strong, sharp flavor that stands out. We love its crumbly yet rich texture which adds depth to any dish. It’s also pretty versatile.

We tried it in mashed potatoes and it was fantastic. It melted just right, adding a savory punch. Use it in soups, salads, or sandwiches. It’s a solid choice for any meal.

Substitute it in a 1:1 ratio for Lancashire. Check out our guide on cheddar cheese substitutes for more inspiration.

6 – Cream Cheese

Alright folks, let’s talk Cream Cheese. It’s smooth, creamy, and slightly tangy. We love it because it spreads like a dream. It’s such a versatile cheese too.

We swapped it for Lancashire in a 1:1 ratio, and it worked great. Melts perfectly in soups and mixed dishes. Adds richness without overpowering.

Toss it on bagels, mix it in casseroles, or use it as a dip. Cream cheese is also fantastic for baking—think creamy cheesecakes. Interested in more swaps? Check out our article on cream cheese substitutes for some tasty ideas.