Short Answer
The best substitute for mayonnaise is plain full-fat Greek yogurt, swapped 1:1, in sandwiches, tuna, chicken and potato salad, and dips.
- Sour cream is the closer match in cake.
- For a vegan plate, mashed avocado covers sandwiches while aquafaba mayo covers salads.
Mayonnaise is mostly oil, held together by egg yolk and sharpened with vinegar or lemon juice, so any swap has to supply fat, creaminess and tang. Before you reach for one of the spread and dressing swaps, work out which job your dish leans on: a cake needs the fat, a sandwich a spreadable cream, and a potato salad a coating that clings to every cube.
When a recipe names Kewpie, a Japanese-style mayo made with egg yolks and rice vinegar, swap in one of the Kewpie mayo stand-ins.
1 What Does Mayonnaise Do in a Recipe?
Anything sold as mayonnaise in the US holds at least 65% vegetable oil by weight, plus egg yolk ingredients and vinegar or lemon juice. That makes it mostly fat:
- On bread the fat keeps a sandwich from tasting dry.
- In tuna or potato salad it coats each piece so the filling holds together.
- In a cake it adds moisture without a greasy crumb.
The yolk keeps the oil and acid blended, and the acid gives the sharp edge you taste.
No swap that is not mayonnaise does all three jobs, so the swap has to match the job your dish leans on. Greek yogurt brings tang and a thick body with little fat, avocado brings fat and no tang, and aquafaba mayo comes closest because it is built from oil and acid like the original.
2 Best Substitutes for Mayonnaise
Greek yogurt and sour cream cover most dishes, avocado and hummus work best on bread, and aquafaba mayo and cashew cream serve a vegan or dairy-free table. Every amount is for 1 cup of mayonnaise and is a starting point, so taste before you add more.
| Substitute | Amount | Best for | What changes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full-fat Greek yogurt | 1 cup | Tuna, chicken, egg and potato salad, dips | Tangier and leaner; can split in a hot oven |
| Sour cream | 1 cup | Dips, slaw, potato salad, cake | Looser and milder than yogurt; denser cake crumb |
| Mashed avocado | 1 cup, or half the mayonnaise in tuna salad | Sandwiches, wraps, tuna salad | No tang until you add lemon; browns within a day or two |
| Hummus | 1 cup, thinned with water a tablespoon at a time | Sandwiches, wraps, burgers | Earthy and nutty; holds sesame |
| Mustard | A thin smear per sandwich | Ham, turkey and roast beef sandwiches | Adds tang only, with almost no fat |
| Cashew cream | 1 cup | Creamy salads, sandwiches, vegan dishes | Mild and nutty; holds tree nuts |
| Aquafaba mayo | 1 cup | Anything that calls for mayonnaise, vegan | Pourable at first; keeps only 4 to 5 days |
| Miracle Whip | 1 cup | Potato salad, coleslaw, deviled eggs | Sweeter and spicier; still holds egg |
1. Full-Fat Greek Yogurt
Greek yogurt is yogurt strained of much of its whey, which leaves it thick enough to hold a spoon upright the way mayonnaise does. Swap it 1:1, using a plain, full-fat tub, because low-fat versions have less body and taste thinner and sharper once they are stirred into tuna or chicken salad.
You can put a cup of yogurt where a cup of mayonnaise went in egg salad, potato salad and creamy dressings alike.
The FDA's yogurt standard starts at 3.25% milkfat, against the 65% oil in mayonnaise, so a yogurt salad tastes lighter and a little flat. Add a pinch more salt than you would with mayonnaise, and stir in a teaspoon of olive oil per cup if the filling tastes lean.
Warning
Keep yogurt away from heat where you can. Cook's Country notes that fat keeps cultured dairy from curdling in heat, and yogurt carries little of it, so a yogurt spread baked on fish or in a casserole can break into curds.
2. Sour Cream
Sour cream is cream soured by bacterial cultures, and the FDA sets its floor at 18% milkfat, which makes it richer and milder than yogurt. Use it 1:1 in dips, coleslaw, and potato or pasta salad. It runs looser than mayonnaise, so for a sandwich spread you will want a spoonful of mustard stirred in to give it bite.
In cake, you get better results from sour cream than from yogurt. Mayonnaise gives a chocolate cake moisture and fat without greasiness, and sour cream supplies both, though the crumb comes out denser and tangier.
- Start at 1:1 with a full-fat tub.
- Greek yogurt adds moisture to a cake but little fat, so it needs a splash of oil beside it.
- A mayonnaise cake usually has no eggs of its own, so a sour cream or yogurt cake needs an egg or egg replacer added back.
If you are vegetarian, read the label, because some brands list gelatin among their stabilizers, and the FDA standard lets makers add safe and suitable ingredients that improve texture. A front label that says organic or natural does not rule gelatin out. Sour cream is dairy, so it never suits a vegan.
3. Mashed Avocado
Ripe avocado spreads almost like mayonnaise and brings fat of its own, which makes it the best swap for sandwiches and wraps. It has no tang, so mash it with a squeeze of lemon juice and a pinch of salt.
In tuna salad, Food Republic suggests replacing half the mayonnaise with mashed avocado, stirring the lemon juice into the avocado before it meets the tuna.
Avocado turns brown once air reaches it. Lemon juice slows that without stopping it, so mash it the morning you plan to eat it and press plastic wrap or parchment against the surface before the lid goes on.
USDA FoodKeeper gives a whole ripe avocado 3 to 4 days in the fridge, and a mashed bowl looks its best for a day or two.
4. Hummus
Hummus is chickpeas blended with tahini, lemon juice and garlic, so it spreads thick and tastes earthy and nutty, with only a little lemon tang. Thin it with water a tablespoon at a time until it spreads like mayonnaise. It suits turkey, roasted vegetable and falafel sandwiches, and burgers, where you want a savory flavor.
Tip
We'd keep it off tuna and chicken salad, because the chickpea taste takes over the fish and the meat.
5. Mustard
Mustard seasons a sandwich but adds almost no fat, so it replaces the tang of mayonnaise and none of its creaminess. A thin smear is enough on ham, turkey or roast beef, because mustard is far sharper than mayonnaise, and thinning it with water only waters down the flavor without adding body.
For a salad, whisk the mustard with olive oil and a little vinegar, the base of vinaigrette-dressed potato salads that skip the creamy dressing.
6. Cashew Cream
Cashew cream is raw cashews blended with water until smooth. Love and Lemons blends 1 cup of raw cashews with ½ cup of water, 2 tablespoons each of olive oil and lemon juice, a clove of garlic and ½ teaspoon of salt, which makes about 1 cup, enough to replace 1 cup of mayonnaise.
A high-speed blender handles unsoaked cashews. With a weaker blender, soak them for at least 4 hours and drain them first, or the cream stays grainy.
- Add the water a spoonful at a time and stop early for a thicker spread that holds on a sandwich.
- The cream keeps up to 5 days in the fridge and separates after freezing, so make it fresh.
- Cashews are a tree nut, which rules the cream out for anyone with a tree nut allergy.
7. Aquafaba Mayo
Aquafaba is the liquid from a can of chickpeas, and blended with oil it holds the oil in a smooth emulsion much as egg yolk does. You blend 3 tablespoons of aquafaba with 1 cup of oil, 2 teaspoons of Dijon mustard, ¾ teaspoon of salt and about 3 tablespoons of lemon juice and vinegar, using an immersion blender, because the Loving It Vegan author reports that neither a food processor nor a stand mixer worked for her.
Aquafaba mayo is pourable at first and thickens in the fridge, and you should use it within 4 to 5 days. It tastes closest to the real thing, so it suits a vegan table, and it still holds a full cup of oil.
8. Miracle Whip
Miracle Whip is the swap for a recipe that wants a sweeter, spicier dressing. It is sold as a dressing because the FDA's salad dressing standard allows as little as 30% vegetable oil, and water, sugar and spices make up the difference.
Mental Floss reports that it has much less fat and more sugar than mayonnaise. You can use it 1:1 in potato salad, coleslaw and deviled eggs, but taste a spoonful first, because the sugar stands out in savory fillings. It still holds egg yolk, so it is no help for an egg allergy.
3 Which Substitute Should You Use for Each Dish?
Greek yogurt needs only a spoon, while aquafaba mayo needs an immersion blender and a cup of oil but is the only one of the two that a vegan guest can eat.
Full-Fat Greek Yogurt
One cup replaces 1 cup of mayonnaise in tuna, chicken or potato salad, and all you need is a spoon, with no cooking and no blender.
It is dairy, so it is not vegan, and it tastes tangier and leaner than mayonnaise.
Aquafaba Mayo
Vegan and the closest in taste, because oil and acid do the work, so it suits sandwiches and salads alike.
It needs an immersion blender and 1 cup of oil, and it keeps only 4 to 5 days.
Past that choice, each dish has its own best swap:
- Sandwiches and wraps. Mashed avocado or thinned hummus gives a spreadable base, and a thin smear of mustard does the job on deli meats.
- Tuna, chicken and egg salad. Greek yogurt holds the pieces together at 1 cup for 1 cup, and in tuna salad you can swap half the mayonnaise for avocado.
- Potato salad and coleslaw. A creamy potato salad dresses its potatoes in mayonnaise whisked with mustard and vinegar, and yogurt or sour cream takes that place at 1 cup for 1 cup. Miracle Whip gives the sweeter deli-style version of potato salad or coleslaw.
- Deviled eggs. The yolks of deviled eggs mash into Greek yogurt the way they mash into mayonnaise, and a spoonful of mustard brings back the tang.
- Dips and dressings. A cup of sour cream or Greek yogurt makes a creamy base at once, and beans give a thicker one, as in bean dips and tzatziki.
- Baking. Sour cream is the first pick for cake, with a full-fat tub at 1:1.
Warning
Salads made with yogurt, avocado or any other binder still belong in the fridge. USDA FSIS says perishable food should not sit out more than 2 hours, or 1 hour when the air is above 90°F, and cold food stays at 40°F or below.
4 Which Mayonnaise Substitutes Work for an Egg Allergy or a Vegan Diet?
Mayonnaise carries egg yolk, and egg is one of the FDA's nine major allergens, so you need to check each swap against the diet of the person eating it as well as the dish.
- Aquafaba mayo and mashed avocado have no egg and no dairy, so you can serve them to an egg-free or a vegan guest.
- Greek yogurt and sour cream have no egg, but milk is another major allergen, and neither is vegan.
- Hummus has no egg or dairy, but tahini is sesame, which became the ninth major allergen on January 1, 2023.
- Cashew cream is free of egg and dairy, but if anyone at your table has a tree nut allergy, skip it.
- Miracle Whip contains egg yolk, so it is out for an egg allergy.
A mayonnaise cake usually has no eggs, because the mayonnaise supplies them, so check your recipe. Sour cream replaces the fat and moisture, but the batter loses the egg yolk, so add one egg, or for an egg-free cake a vegan egg substitute such as ground flax or chia.
5 Which Swaps Should You Skip?
Low-fat and nonfat yogurt or sour cream have the least body, so they turn watery in a salad and leave a cake less moist. Mustard alone cannot bind a salad, because it has no fat, and enough of it to coat a cup of potatoes would taste harsh.
Avocado is a poor choice for a salad you make the night before a gathering, since it browns by morning.
Frequently Asked Questions
Some are. Mayonnaise is at least 65% oil by weight, sour cream starts at 18% milkfat and the yogurt standard starts at 3.25%, so full-fat yogurt is far leaner. Avocado, hummus and cashew cream carry their own fat, and aquafaba mayo uses a full cup of oil.
USDA FoodKeeper lists 2 months in the fridge after opening for commercial mayonnaise. Homemade versions, including aquafaba mayo, keep for days and not months, so make them in small batches.
Mayonnaise browns bread because it is mostly oil, and soft butter or olive oil spread thin on the outside of the bread browns it the same way.
Sources
- FDA, 21 CFR 169.140: Mayonnaise
- FDA, 21 CFR 169.150: Salad dressing
- FDA, 21 CFR 131.160: Sour cream
- FDA, 21 CFR 131.200: Yogurt
- FDA: FASTER Act, Sesame as the Ninth Major Food Allergen
- USDA FSIS: Barbecue and Picnic Food Safety
- USDA FoodKeeper: Mayonnaise and Avocados
- Cook's Country: All About Crème Fraîche
- Food Republic: Mayonnaise in Chocolate Cake
- Food Republic: Avocado in Tuna Salad
- Love and Lemons: Cashew Cream
- Loving It Vegan: Aquafaba Mayonnaise
- Mental Floss: What Is Miracle Whip?

Andrew Gray is a seasoned food writer and blogger with a wealth of experience in the restaurant and catering industries. With a passion for all things delicious, Andrew has honed his culinary expertise through his work as a personal chef and caterer.
His love for food led him to venture into food writing, where he has contributed to various online publications, sharing his knowledge and insights on the culinary world. As the proud owner of CooksCrafter.com, Andrew covers a wide range of topics, including recipes, restaurant reviews, product recommendations, and culinary tips.
Through his website, he aims to inspire and educate fellow food enthusiasts, offering a comprehensive resource for all things food-related.








