Skip to Content

Spice Up Dishes: 5 Substitutes for Padron Peppers

Who says you need Padron peppers to bring the heat and flavor to your cooking? Sometimes, you either can’t find them, or you’re looking to shake things up in the kitchen.

Good news – there’s a whole variety of other peppers and ingredients out there that can fit the bill, adding just the right amount of kick and flavor to your dishes.

From sweet and smoky to fiery and bold, these substitutes have got you covered. Whether you’re whipping up a sizzling stir-fry, a hearty casserole, or a zesty salsa, these alternatives will help keep your meals exciting and delicious.

1 – Shishito Peppers

Alright, first up on our substitution list are Shishito peppers. These little guys are a great swap for Padron peppers because they bring a similar level of heat – which, by the way, is mild.

Most of the time, you get a nice, gentle warmth, but every once in a while, you’ll bite into one that packs a surprising punch. They’re perfect for when you want a bit of excitement without going overboard on the spice.

Using Shishito peppers in your cooking is pretty straightforward. For every Padron pepper your recipe calls for, swap in an equal amount of Shishito peppers. It’s that simple.

And hey, if you’re curious about other ways to switch things up or need more ideas, check out this handy guide on finding the right Shishito pepper substitutes. It’s packed with tips to keep your dishes fresh and exciting.

2 – Cubanelle Peppers

Next up, meet Cubanelle peppers. These are your go-to if you’re searching for something a tad sweeter with a mild heat that won’t scare anyone away.

They’re an awesome choice for adding a bit of zest without overwhelming your dish. Plus, their bright, vibrant color definitely brings some extra visual appeal to your plate.

When it comes to swapping in Cubanelle peppers for Padron ones, keep it easy. Use them at a one-to-one ratio. That means if your recipe says, “Add one Padron pepper,” you grab one Cubanelle pepper instead. No sweat. 

Cubanelle peppers work wonders in dishes where you want a subtle spice kick but nothing too crazy. They’re particularly good in salads, sautés, or stuffed recipes.

3 – Anaheim Peppers

Now, let’s talk Anaheim peppers. These peppers are a fantastic choice if you’re missing Padron peppers but still want to keep things interesting.

The reason? Anaheim peppers bring a hint more heat than Padrons, but not so much that it’ll knock your socks off. They’re just right for upping the spice without making your eyes water.

Anaheim peppers are also a bit larger, which means they’re great for stuffing or adding into dishes where you want the pepper to be the star of the show. Just slice ’em, dice ’em, or stuff ’em, and you’re all set.

For swapping them in, use one Anaheim pepper for every Padron pepper the recipe asks for. If they seem a lot bigger, you should cut them down to match the size you need. 

4 – Jalapeño Peppers

Jalapeño peppers are a great alternative to Padron peppers, offering a slightly higher heat level for those who like a bit of extra spice. They’re readily available in most stores, making them easy to find.

For substitutions, use Jalapeños in a one-to-one ratio with Padron peppers, but adjust the amount based on your spice preference. Add more for heat and less for mildness.

Jalapeños are versatile, perfect for salsas, tacos, or adding a spicy kick to any dish. For more Jalapeño substitute ideas or other options, check out this guide: finding the right Jalapeño substitutes.

5 – Banana Peppers

Last but not least are Banana peppers, a fantastic Padron pepper substitute. They’re mild, adding sweet tanginess to dishes without the heat. They also bring a pop of yellow, making your dish look and taste great.

Substituting Banana peppers for Padron peppers is easy. Just use them in the same quantity your recipe requires. No math is needed.

Banana peppers are great in sandwiches, pizzas, and salads, adding a unique flavor that makes your meal pop. For more Banana pepper substitutes, check out this straightforward guide here. It has everything you need to elevate your kitchen game.