Skip to Content

5 Tasty Swaps for Wisconsin Brick Cheese in Recipes

Wisconsin Brick Cheese is awesome, but sometimes we need a swap.

You know how it goes. There’s a recipe calling for that distinct, creamy flavor, and here we are searching for something similar. We’ve all been there. Whether you’re out of it or just feeling adventurous, you need options.

We’ve rounded up five great alternatives. These cheeses bring their own twist while keeping your dish tasty. Let’s jump right in and see what makes these swaps worth trying.

5 Easy Substitutes for Wisconsin Brick Cheese

For experienced cheeseheads, it’s no surprise brick cheese was born in Wisconsin. This semi-soft cheese is creamy and buttery, rich with tangy flavors that make you want to slap a slice between two slices of bread.

But what else can do the trick? Turns out, there are plenty of options if you’re willing to experiment. Here are five alternatives that will liven up recipes calling for brick cheese:

1 – Monterey Jack Cheese

Monterey Jack Cheese is super versatile. It’s mild, melty, and slightly nutty.

If you like gooey, you’re in for a treat. This cheese melts like a dream, perfect for sandwiches or baked dishes.

It’s got a smooth, buttery flavor. Nothing too overpowering.

Try a 1:1 swap with brick cheese in any recipe. Works well in casseroles, grilled cheese, or even as a pizza topping.

Check out this Monterey Jack Cheese substitutes article for more options if you’re curious.

We love using it for quick mac n’ cheese. Toss it in and watch it melt!

2 – Muenster Cheese

Muenster cheese is one of our favorites. It’s mild, creamy, and melts like a dream. Perfect for melting. You can throw it in sandwiches or baked dishes.

For recipes that need brick cheese, try a 1:1 substitute ratio. It brings a smooth, buttery flavor without taking over the dish. Perfect for casseroles, grilled cheese, and pizza toppings.

We love how versatile it is. It fits into so many different recipes. Want to learn more? Check out this Muenster Cheese substitutes article for more ideas.

3 – Provolone Cheese

Provolone cheese is a solid choice for many recipes. We love it for its smooth texture and mild flavor.

It’s semi-soft and melts beautifully, making it perfect for hot dishes. Swap brick cheese with Provolone at a 1:1 ratio.

It’s ideal for grilled cheese sandwiches, pizzas, and casseroles. Trust us, it adds a subtle richness that enhances any dish.

Need more details? Check out this Provolone Cheese substitutes article for other great options.

We find it makes homemade lasagna extra special. It’s like a little cheesy hug in every bite.

4 – Cheddar Cheese

In case you didn’t know, cheddar cheese is the most popular type of cheese in the United States. And we can see why.

It’s creamy with a sharp bite and melts perfectly for all kinds of recipes (hello, mac n’ cheese). Swap brick cheese with cheddar at a 1:1 ratio.

One thing to note: it has a stronger flavor than brick cheese, so adjust accordingly based on your personal taste.

Looking for more options? Check out this Cheddar Cheese substitutes article for some great alternatives.

5 – Gouda Cheese

Gouda cheese is rich, creamy, and melts beautifully. It’s perfect for dishes needing brick cheese. We use the same amount: a 1:1 ratio.

It’s got a sweet, nutty flavor. Ideal for sandwiches and baked dishes. Plus, it adds a nice depth.

We’ve used it in grilled cheese, casseroles, and pizzas. It works wonders. Gouda’s versatility makes it a great option. We love it, it’s simple. Easy to find and always tasty.

Want more ideas? Check out this Gouda Cheese substitutes article.