Skip to Content

7 Buttermilk Powder Substitutes: Flavor It Up

Have you ever faced a buttermilk crisis just before starting your pancakes? We have, and trust us, it’s a total breakfast bummer.

But guess what? There’s no need to cancel brunch plans! We’ve found some fantastic buttermilk powder substitutes that you probably already have in your kitchen.

From yogurt to lemon juice, these alternatives will save your recipes and maybe even taste better.

Why settle for plain when you can have delicious options at hand? Let’s keep our pancakes fluffy and our smiles wide.

7 Easy Substitutes for Buttermilk Powder

For those who aren’t familiar with buttermilk powder, it’s essentially dried buttermilk that can be reconstituted with water to create a liquid form of the tangy and slightly acidic dairy product. It’s commonly used in baking recipes to add moisture and flavor to cakes, biscuits, and other treats.

But what if you don’t have any buttermilk powder on hand? Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered! Here are seven easy substitutes for buttermilk powder:

1 – Yogurt and Acid

First off, who knew a simple mix of yogurt and lemon juice could save the day? It’s super easy and straightforward. Just blend plain yogurt with a bit of lemon juice, and you’ve got a near-perfect substitute.

We’ve tested it, and the flavor is spot on. The tanginess from the yogurt and the acidity from the lemon juice mimic buttermilk really well. It works wonders in pancakes and biscuits. We even tried it in our favorite cake recipe, and it added a lovely moist texture.

Give this combo a shot, and you’ll be surprised at how seamlessly it fits into your dishes.

2 – Sour Cream and Water

Next on our list is an underdog: sour cream and water. This combo is a bit richer and creamier compared to buttermilk powder. Mix equal parts sour cream with water to lighten it up. This substitute offers a slight tang and silkier texture, perfect for quick bread and muffins.

Flavor-wise, it’s a close match to the original buttermilk experience. We used this in our pancakes and the result was fluffy and delicious. It also works great in savory dishes like cornbread. Over here, we love the versatility it offers. For other alternatives, check out our sour cream substitutes guide.

3 – Milk and Vinegar

When it comes to baking, milk and vinegar is a classic substitute for buttermilk powder. For every cup of buttermilk powder, mix one tablespoon of white vinegar with enough milk to make one cup. Let the mixture sit for a few minutes before using it in your recipe.

The acidity from the vinegar reacts with the protein in the milk, giving you a similar tangy flavor as buttermilk powder. This is great for recipes that need both moisture and lift, like cakes and muffins.

4 – Kefir and Water

Kefir is like that friend who always brings the sour patch to the party. We love how it has a tangy bite that can elevate our baked goods. Just mix kefir with water, and you’ve got a simple yet effective buttermilk substitute.

The tanginess is more pronounced but in a delightful way. It gives our pancakes a slight zing that is hard to beat. The texture remains smooth and creamy, making it perfect for both sweet and savory recipes.

Curious about other substitutes? Check out our kefir substitutes guide for more options.

5 – Buttermilk and Lemon Juice

The magic duo: buttermilk and lemon juice. Crave that tangy kick with a twist? This combo is your go-to. Simply mix one cup of buttermilk with a tablespoon of fresh lemon juice.

The result? A zesty, creamy texture that dances on your taste buds. We love how it adds moisture without overwhelming other flavors. Perfect for pancakes, cakes, or a biscuit upgrade.

The lemon juice adds that extra zing, elevating the buttermilk’s natural tang. For more buttermilk secrets, check out our buttermilk substitutes guide. You won’t believe how easy it is!

6 – Coconut Cream and Acid

If you love tropical vibes in your food, coconut cream and acid is your new best friend. Picture this: rich, creamy coconut with a tangy twist. Instant island magic. Mix equal parts coconut cream with lemon or lime juice.

We gave it a try in our pancakes, and wow, they were luscious and tender. The coconut flavor was subtle but noticeable. This combo is a superb option if you’re out of buttermilk powder. It’s creamy and adds a fresh taste to your dishes.

Check out our guide for more coconut cream substitutes. Experimenting never tasted so good.

7 – Nutritional Yeast and Water

Last on our list but let’s not underestimate it: nutritional yeast and water. This combo is more unique compared to the others. Mix a tablespoon of nutritional yeast with a cup of water to get a creamy, slightly cheesy liquid.

The result? A flavor that’s savory and rich. It’s not just tangy but also packs a hint of umami. Perfect for adding depth to your recipes.

Ideal for those who love experimenting with flavors. It transformed our pancakes, giving them a cool, unexpected twist. Interested in other alternatives? Check out our nutritional yeast substitutes guide for more hacks.