Skip to Content

7 Top Haddock Substitutes: Explore New Flavors

Trying to switch up the dinner menu after eating haddock for the umpteenth time? We’ve got you. Fish can be boring when you stick to the same kind every time.

So, we’re here to introduce new flavors and make those taste buds dance. Ever heard of swapping haddock for something else? It’s like trading in an old bike for a snazzy new scooter. Trust us, your palate will thank you.

Got that shopping list ready? We’ve compiled a list of seven haddock alternatives that are just as tasty and versatile.

7 Top Substitutes for Haddock

When it comes to seafood, there are plenty of options out there. Some substitutes for haddock may be more familiar than others, but don’t let that stop you from trying something new! Here are our top picks:

SubstituteTasteTextureRatioSuitable Dishes
CodMild, slightly sweetFirm, flaky1:1Fish and chips, baked fish, fish tacos
PollockMild, slightly sweetFirm, flaky1:1Fish stew, fish cakes, fish sandwiches
TilapiaMild, slightly sweetFirm, flaky1:1Grilled fish, fish tacos, fish stew
HalibutMild, slightly sweetFirm, dense1:1Baked fish, fish and chips, fish chowder
FlounderMild, slightly sweetDelicate, flaky1:1Sautéed fish, fish tacos, fish stew
SoleMild, slightly sweetDelicate, flaky1:1Meunière, fish tacos, fish stew
CatfishMild, slightly sweetFirm, flaky1:1Blackened fish, fish stew, fish cakes

1 – Cod

Cod is the go-to fish when you’re out of haddock. It’s got a similar mild and slightly sweet flavor that’s super easy to love. We’re talking flaky goodness that you can swap 1:1 in any recipe.

Cod is a bit firmer and less delicate than haddock. This means it holds up better in more robust dishes.

Got a little extra time? Cod has a slightly longer cooking time, but it’s still a breeze. Plus, it’s often cheaper than haddock, so that’s a win.

Craving more info? Check out these alternative cod fish substitutes for even more ideas.

2 – Pollock

Our next pick is pollock. Think of it as haddock’s mellow cousin. Pollock is another affordable white fish that works wonders in place of haddock.

It has a milder flavor and a more delicate texture than cod. So, it’s gentler on the palate. We love using pollock as a 1:1 swap for haddock in recipes.

Pollock’s cooking time is shorter too. Quick and easy, right? Pollock turns more translucent when cooked, just a heads-up.

Also, it’s super sustainable and eco-friendly.

3 – Tilapia

Another sweet option perfect for a budget-friendly swap. Tilapia hits the mark with its super mild and slightly sweet taste. It’s got a tender, flaky texture that matches well with haddock recipes.

Substitute tilapia 1:1 for haddock. Easy! Tilapia is more opaque when cooked, making it look a bit different on your plate. No big deal.

It cooks quicker than haddock, saving time. Bonus? Tilapia is one of the most affordable white fish options. Wanna explore more options with tilapia? Check out these tilapia substitutes for more info.

4 – Halibut

When you’re ready to take your fish game up a notch, halibut is your friend. Don’t let the higher price tag scare you off.

Halibut’s texture? Firm and meaty. This makes it a stellar haddock stand-in. Its slight sweetness, coupled with a buttery flavor, adds richness to any dish. Plus, you can swap halibut 1:1 for haddock in recipes.

Expect a longer cook time. Halibut’s thicker, more pronounced flavor profile demands it.

Curious about other options? Check out these halibut substitutes for more ideas.

5 – Flounder

The flounder hits different. It’s delicate and flaky, making it an awesome swap for haddock. Flounder’s mild, slightly sweet flavor is easy to love. Use it as a 1:1 swap for haddock in any recipe.

It cooks faster and is gentler on the texture, which we think is a win. Plus, it’s usually more affordable than haddock, so it’s kind to your wallet too. Want more fishy options? Check out these flounder substitutes to keep things interesting.

Flounder’s tender texture makes every bite delightful. You’ll appreciate its quicker cooking time, giving you dinner on the table faster.

6 – Sole

So, ready for a switch-up?

Sole is flounder’s close cousin and works wonders as a haddock substitute. It’s got that mild, sweet taste we love, plus a super delicate texture. Use it as a 1:1 swap for haddock without changing up your recipe.

Sole cooks quicker and has a more translucent look when done. Watch out though, sole is often pricier than flounder.

Check out some more sole substitute ideas to keep your meals interesting.

7 – Catfish

Our final haddock swap is catfish, and it’s a tasty one! Catfish has a firmer texture and a more pronounced flavor than haddock, but it works great in some recipes. We love how it’s mild with a slightly sweet, nutty taste.

Use catfish as a 1:1 swap for haddock without thinking twice. It has a thicker, meatier texture, making it stand out on your plate.

Catfish does take a bit longer to cook, so plan accordingly. If you’re interested in knowing more, check out these awesome catfish substitutes.