Skip to Content

7 Easy Piquillo Pepper Substitutes: Pepper Your Palate

Piquillo peppers hold a special spot in our hearts. Remember those summer BBQs? We all loved the taste they added to our dishes.

Finding the right substitute can be tricky, yet we’ve got you covered. We took it upon ourselves to experiment. Our kitchens turned into labs, testing each alternative to see how close we could get to that original piquillo pepper flavor.

Our choices? They’re spot-on. We’re excited to share our finds, perfect for any recipe needing that unique piquillo pepper twist.

7 Easy Substitutes for Piquillo Peppers

While nothing can fully replicate the taste of piquillo peppers, these substitutes come close and add a delicious twist to your dishes.

1 – Guajillo Peppers

Guajillo peppers bring a mild heat to dishes, scoring between 2,500 to 5,000 on the Scoville Heat Units. We found them as a flavorful stand-in for piquillo peppers.

They’re less sweet, yet their earthy tone complements meats and sauces well. We used a 1:1 ratio in our recipes, and the results were fantastic.

For those eager to learn more about substituting peppers, check out our guide on finding alternatives to guajillo peppers.

Our kitchen experiments prove guajillo peppers work brilliantly. They’re versatile and accessible, making any dish pop with flavor.

2 – Pimento Peppers

Pimento peppers, mild and sweet, step in nicely for piquillo. They’re less fiery, rating 500 to 1000 SHU, perfect for those who prefer a gentler heat.

We found them great for stuffing or in salads, using a one-to-one swap in our dishes. Their tender flesh and vibrant color light up any plate. They shine in recipes that call for a subtle warmth without overpowering other flavors.

For an in-depth guide on alternatives to pimento peppers, our findings are detailed at comprehensive alternatives to pimento peppers.

3 – Cherry Peppers

Cherry peppers are bold and vibrant, perfect for adding a pop of flavor and color to any dish. We discovered they’re an awesome swap for piquillo peppers.

They pack a mild heat, about 2,500 to 5,000 SHU, making them a versatile choice. In our recipes, we found that a 1:1 substitution ratio worked like a charm.

Their sweetness surprised us, a perfect balance to their heat. Ideal for dishes needing a touch of warmth without too much spice.

Interested in more cherry pepper swaps? Get the scoop on alternative selections to cherry peppers here.

4 – Anaheim Peppers

Anaheim peppers are the buddies we needed for our recipes needing a less spicy kick. They bring a mild heat, hitting 500 to 1,500 SHU, making them a cool alternative for those lesser spice days. We used them one-for-one in place of piquillo peppers, and wow, they did not disappoint.

Their larger size made our stuffed recipes look like we actually knew what we were doing. For more tips on swapping peppers, our discoveries are shared in a guide on finding flavorful alternatives to Anaheim peppers. Trust our experience; these peppers blend seamlessly into dishes, letting everyone think you’re a bit of a pepper pro.

5 – Jalapeno Peppers

Jalapenos offer a zesty kick, hitting the scales at 4,000 to 8,000 SHU. We swap them in one-for-one, boosting dishes with vibrancy.

Their kick elevates meals, unlike the subtle piquillo. For those seeking a bolder taste,

jalapenos fit perfectly. To compare, they pack more heat but retain a similar brightness.

Each bite infused our recipes with an exciting spark. Check out other spicy additions in our guide on hot pepper swaps.

Learn how to balance heat in your dishes by consulting our thorough review of jalapeno alternatives.

6 – Poblano Peppers

Poblano peppers bring a gentle heat, around 1,000 to 2,000 SHU, perfect for mild spice lovers. We use them in a straight swap for piquillo peppers. Their size makes them ideal for stuffing, adding a milder zing to our dishes.

If you’re into tweaking flavors, stuffing Poblanos made our meals pop without overpowering. They mesh well in most recipes, enhancing without altering the dish’s core taste.

For those intrigued by adjusting pepper flavors in meals, glancing through our insights on Poblano pepper alternatives might spark interest.

7 – Nora Peppers

Nora peppers mirror piquillo’s sweetness, yet milder. We swap them one-to-one in dishes. They clock in at 1,000 to 2,000 SHU, just a touch of warmth.

In our food adventures, these peppers added a subtle depth. Perfect for those who enjoy a hint of spice without the fire. Their size and fleshiness make recipes visually appealing.