Skip to Content

Simple Substitutes for Poblano Peppers: 5 Tasty Options

Say you’re all set to whip up that recipe you’ve been eyeing, only to realize you’re fresh out of poblano peppers. Hold up, no need to scrap your cooking plans just yet!

This article is here to save your dish and spice up your meal with five fantastic alternatives.

Whether it’s a kick of heat or a mild zing you’re missing, we’ve got your back with options that might already be in your pantry or are easy to find. From the unexpected twists to the closest matches, you’re covered.

5 Best Substitutes for Poblano Peppers

1 – Anaheim Peppers

Anaheim Peppers are a fantastic stand-in for Poblanos when you’re looking to dial down the heat without losing flavor. These guys are milder, meaning they won’t set your mouth on fire but still add that special something to your dishes.

A 1:1 swap works perfectly, so if your recipe calls for a cup of Poblanos, just use a cup of Anaheims instead.

What makes them great? They’re versatile – think stuffing, roasting, or slicing into salads. Plus, they’re easier to find in most grocery stores if Poblanos are playing hard to get. 

And hey, if you’re curious about even more ways to use Anaheim peppers or find yourself short on them, too, check out this handy guide on Anaheim pepper substitutes. It’s like finding a hidden treasure in your kitchen explorations.

2 – Cubanelle Peppers

Cubanelle Peppers is your go-to when you need a substitute with a bit more zest than Anaheim but still less fiery than Poblanos.

Why do they rock? Well, they have a slightly sweet vibe and can jazz up any recipe without overwhelming it. For every poblano pepper your recipe needs, you can safely swap in an equivalent amount of Cubanelle.

They’re awesome for stir-fries, stuffed dishes, or just adding a pop of color and flavor to your meal. Plus, they’re pretty easy to bump into at your local market. Got no Cubanelles either?

No stress. Hop over to this guide for some Cubanelle pepper substitutes that are just as chill and easy to use.

3 – Bell Peppers

Bell Peppers are the superheroes when you don’t have poblano peppers. Why? Because they’re sweet, not spicy, and can fit into almost any dish you’re making.

They bring color and a mild flavor that doesn’t overpower the other ingredients. For every poblano pepper needed, just use the same amount of bell pepper.

They’re perfect for those who prefer their food on the milder side but still want a hint of that pepper essence in their meals.

You can find bell peppers pretty much anywhere, making them a super convenient option. And if you’re looking to shake things up a bit with different types of bell peppers or need a backup plan, this guide on bell pepper substitutes has some cool ideas worth checking out.

4 – Jalapeño Peppers

Jalapeño Peppers add a spicy kick when you’re out of poblanos. They’re hotter, so they pack more punch in your dishes.

Use half the amount your recipe calls for poblanos to keep the heat manageable. They’re great for adding a bit of heat to any dish without going overboard.

You can chop them into salsas, slice them for toppings, or dice them for a spicy bite in your meals. They’re everywhere in stores, so you won’t have a hard time finding them.

If jalapeños are too hot for you or you’re just looking for something different, peep this list of jalapeño substitutes for other spicy options.

5 – Guajillo Peppers

Guajillo pepper is your secret weapon when you’re out of poblanos and craving something with a bit more depth. They bring a smoky flavor to the table that’s hard to beat.

They’re not as hot as jalapeños but pack enough heat to add excitement to your meal. Use them in a 2:1 ratio – for every poblano, use half the amount of guajillo to keep things balanced.

They work wonders in sauces, stews, and meat dishes. Finding them might take a trip to a specialty store, but it’s worth it for the unique flavor they offer.

Plus, they give dishes a gorgeous red hue that makes food look as good as it tastes.