Skip to Content

7 Farmer’s Cheese Substitutes: Add Some Zing

Farmer’s cheese. We know it well. But what if your grocery store is out or you just want to experiment?

Let’s talk cheesy alternatives. Farmer’s cheese is versatile and mild. We love its creamy texture. It works in so many dishes.

However, sometimes you’ve got to switch it up. Tried making a dish and found you had no farmer’s cheese on hand?

We’ve been there. Good news, there are substitutes that bring that zing. Here are our top picks to save your recipes.

7 Easy Substitutes for Farmer’s Cheese

The right farmer’s cheese substitute adds the perfect tang and texture to your dish. Here are our 7 top picks:

1 – Ricotta Cheese

Ricotta cheese is super versatile and creamy. It’s an awesome substitute for farmer’s cheese. You can find it in most stores, and it’s easy to use. We like how it blends with pasta and lasagna.

Swap farmer’s cheese with ricotta at a 1:1 ratio. Simple, right? Ricotta’s soft texture and mild flavor make it easy for several dishes.

We tried this swap in our lasagna, and it worked perfectly. If you’re also interested, read more about ricotta cheese substitutes.

That’s it. Fast and easy. Ricotta’s ready to go!

2 – Cottage Cheese

Cottage cheese is another excellent option. It has a mild flavor and moist texture, making it handy in many recipes.

Swap farmer’s cheese with cottage cheese in a 1:1 ratio. We love how easy it is to find. Smooth and creamy, it blends well in dishes.

It works particularly well in lasagna and stuffed shells. Perfect for those quick dinners. We’ve swapped it in our favorite dips too.

If you want more cottage cheese ideas, check out this cottage cheese substitutes guide. Simple, versatile, and always ready.

3 – Cream Cheese

Cream cheese is our go-to for creamy goodness. It’s dense, spreadable, and very smooth.

Perfect for desserts or bagels. Swap farmer’s cheese for cream cheese in a 1:1 ratio.

One thing we love is its versatility. You can use it in both sweet and savory dishes.

The tangy flavor is a huge plus. It adds a nice punch to casseroles and cheesecake.

We’ve tested it in a dip, and it was fab. For more tips, check out this cream cheese substitutes guide.

Simple yet effective. Cream cheese works wonders in many recipes.

4 – Feta Cheese

For a tangy and salty kick, try feta cheese as a substitute for farmer’s cheese. It adds a distinct Mediterranean flavor to your dishes.

Swap at a 1:1 ratio (1 cup of farmer’s cheese = 1 cup of feta). Gives that added zing in salads or wraps.

We’ve even used it as an alternative filling for pierogies and crepes. Check out more feta cheese substitutes here.

5 – Queso Fresco

If you’re after a milder cheese, give queso fresco a shot. It’s soft, crumbly, and creamy, making it a great swap for farmer’s cheese.

Swap at a 1:1 ratio or experiment with different amounts to find your desired flavor.

We love using queso fresco in tacos and enchiladas for that authentic taste. For more ideas, check out this queso fresco substitutes guide.

Ditch the blandness and add some Mexican flair to your dishes with queso fresco.

6 – Paneer Cheese

Paneer cheese is a must-try substitute for farmer’s cheese. It’s firm and non-melting, making it ideal for frying or grilling. Swap with paneer at a 1:1 ratio.

We love using paneer in palak paneer, a simple, flavorful spinach curry. It absorbs sauces well and holds its shape.

Great for adding texture and body to dishes. We’ve experimented with it in wraps and salads to much success.

If you’re interested in more, check out this guide on Paneer cheese substitutes.

7 – Greek Yogurt

Last but not least, Greek yogurt makes a fantastic substitute for farmer’s cheese. It’s creamy and tangy, perfect for savory dishes.

Swap at a 1:1 ratio or use less if you want a milder flavor. We love it in dips and sauces. Plus, it adds protein to your meals!

It also works well as a topping for baked potatoes or salads. For more ideas, check out this Greek yogurt substitutes guide.