Skip to Content

6 Easy Kefalotyri Cheese Substitutes: Punch Up Recipes

Let’s talk about kefalotyri cheese substitutes. This Greek cheese is a staple and packs a unique punch in recipes. But what if we can’t find it?

Before you panic, remember: we’ve got options. From everyday cheese like Parmesan to more adventurous choices like Pecorino Romano, replacements are out there.

Now, here’s the fun part. When we last ran out of kefalotyri during a dinner party, we scrambled and grabbed what we had.

That was Parmesan, and it worked like a charm! Join us as we share six easy swaps for this cheese. Ready? Let’s get started.

6 Easy Substitutes for Kefalotyri Cheese

For a quick rundown, we whipped up a table to see how our favorite swaps compare. One thing’s for sure: each of these kefalotyri cheese substitutes will bring its own unique flavor to the dish.

SubstituteTasteTextureRatioSuitable Dishes
Pecorino RomanoSharp, salty, nuttyHard, crumbly1:1Pasta, salads, pizza
Parmesan CheeseIntense, savory, umamiHard, grated1:1Pasta, risotto, soups
Halloumi CheeseSalty, slightly tangyFirm, squeaky1:1Grilled dishes, salads, omelets
Feta CheeseTangy, saltyCrumbly1:1Greek salads, dips, pasta
Gruyère CheeseNutty, slightly sweetFirm, creamy1:1Gratins, soups, sandwiches
Manchego CheeseNutty, slightly sharpFirm, slightly crumbly1:1Tapas, salads, cheese boards

1 – Pecorino Romano

For those who love Greek cuisine, you know the importance of Kefalotyri cheese. It’s commonly used in dishes like saganaki (fried cheese) and pastitsio (baked pasta dish). However, if you can’t find it at your local grocery store, don’t worry – there’s a great substitute: Pecorino Romano.

Pecorino Romano is an Italian hard sheep’s milk cheese that has a similar salty and tangy flavor to Kefalotyri. It also has a firm texture that makes it perfect for grating over dishes or melting.

You can use Pecorino Romano in a 1:1 ratio to replace Kefalotyri in your Greek dishes. It will add a delicious depth of flavor and a touch of saltiness to your meals.

Bonus tip: Pecorino Romano also makes for a great substitute in salads, soups, and even as a topping for pizza.

Pecorino Romano is salty and firm. This Italian cheese is a close match to kefalotyri.

2 – Parmesan Cheese

Why swap kefalotyri with Parmesan?

First, Parmesan is easy to find and versatile. It’s perfect for pasta, salads, and soups. We use Parmesan regularly in our kitchen.

The taste: strong and nutty. It works well one-to-one.

Its firm texture makes it great for grating. Our friends loved it in their pesto. For more ideas, check our Parmesan cheese substitutes article.

It’s a reliable replacement for kefalotyri. Simple, right? Try Parmesan next time you’re out of kefalotyri.

3 – Halloumi Cheese

Halloumi is firm and briny, perfect for grilling because of its high melting point. We love tossing it in salads and sandwiches.

It’s super versatile and works great fried, too. Use it one-to-one in recipes; it holds its shape when cooked, unlike kefalotyri. This makes it awesome for skewers and grill plates.

Our friend swapped it in a vegetarian kebab, and they absolutely loved it. For more tips, check out our article on Halloumi cheese substitutes. It’s a great read if you’re exploring alternative cheeses.

4 – Feta Cheese

In case you’re not familiar with it, feta is a brined cheese that packs a big, tangy kick. It’s versatile, too.

We love using it in salads and as an ingredient in dips. It’s also tasty on pizza! Use one-to-one for kefalotyri substitution.

Our friends tested feta and gave it two thumbs up! For more ideas, see our feta cheese substitutes article.

Next time you run out of kefalotyri, give feta a try!

5 – Gruyère Cheese

Ever tried Gruyère? We have, and it’s a fantastic substitute. The taste is nutty and slightly sweet.

We often use it for baking and melted dishes. It melts beautifully, making it ideal for fondue and grilled cheese.

The texture is semi-hard, so it’s easy to grate. Use it in a one-to-one swap with kefalotyri.

Our friend substituted Gruyère in a cheesy casserole, and it was amazing. For more ideas, check our full guide on Gruyère cheese substitutes.

6 – Manchego Cheese

Last, but certainly not least, we have Manchego. It’s a Spanish cheese that’s mildly salty and has a buttery texture. This cheese is semi-hard and easy to grate or slice.

We love using Manchego in tapas. It’s also great in salads. Substitute it one-to-one for kefalotyri. It works wonders in recipes where you need a rich flavor.

Personal story, our friend tried Manchego in a savory pie. They loved it! For more details, see our complete guide to Manchego cheese substitutes.