Skip to Content

5 Tasty Substitutes for Bell Pepper Your Kitchen Needs

Imagine a world full of vibrant colors and tastes, and at the heart of it all are bell peppers. Picture any meal, and chances are bell peppers, whether green, red, or yellow, have played a starring role, bringing a unique burst of flavor to our dishes.

But what if, in a surprising turn of events, we found ourselves without these colorful culinary staples? Imagine walking into the grocery store to find the bell pepper section empty, marked by an ‘Out of Order’ sign.

We know, it’s a scary thought. But don’t worry, we’ve got you covered with some delicious bell pepper substitutes that will save the day.

5 Tasty Bell Pepper Substitutes Your Kitchen Needs

1 – Poblano Peppers

Substituting with poblanos opens up a world of depth and mild heat, a far cry from the bright refreshment of bell peppers. Think neighborly yet nuanced with a smoky hint of earthiness.

Poblanos thrive in sauces, particularly noted for the classic Mexican dish, Chiles Rellenos, and sing harmoniously in a plethora of soups. Their wide, glistening profile welcomes a thoughtful stuffing, hinting at roasted tomatoes, and creamed corn as a potential marriage.

To execute the poblano switcheroo gracefully, consider the quantities – usually, one poblano can stand in for a cup of chopped bell pepper, but trust your tongue’s wisdom. They require a little tender, ‘grilling’ love to coax out their full-bodied character, and remember, the longer they roast, the richer their flavor.

2 – Cubanelle Peppers

Enter Cubanelles, the subtle sibling of the pepper clan. Their thin flesh belies a gentle, tangy, and slightly sweet undertone that accentuates cooked dishes with a finesse similar to bell peppers.

They’re delightful in omelets, stir-fries, and might just steal the spotlight in your next homemade salsa. In terms of texture, cubanelles match the crunch of bell peppers, but their size is more akin to a banana pepper or an Italian frying pepper.

When swapping for Cubanelles, up the quantities just a smidge – roughly about 1.5 times that of a standard bell pepper amount to account for their slender build. A few quick tosses in the skillet is all it takes before the Cubanelles release their aromatic signature into the food.

3 – Anaheim Peppers

Anaheims peppers stand as a shining example at the less fiery end of the pepper scale, offering just a hint of heat that perfectly balances their mellow and slightly fruity notes.

These peppers have a unique flavor profile that leans towards the savory side, making them an ideal choice for dishes that benefit from a depth of flavor without overwhelming spiciness.

They are particularly effective in enhancing the flavors of kormas and chilis, where their subtle heat and savory notes can meld harmoniously with other ingredients. Additionally, when sliced and grilled, they become sizzling companions in fajitas, adding a delightful complexity that elevates the dish to new heights.

Look to use a one-to-one ratio when replacing with Anaheims, but be ready to adjust the spice elsewhere in your dish. Slow-cooking with Anaheims allows their essence to meld deliciously, making them ideal for simmering stews and taming the flame to your taste.

4 – Banana Peppers

Turning to banana peppers is an exploration through sweetness laced with a mild tang. They might not offer the robust presence of bell peppers, but in certain dishes, they shine bright.

Pickle your way into anti-pasto platters, drizzle outings, or give a piquant addition to your favorite sandwich – the choice is yours! The hint of heat they bring to the table can transform your tastebuds, adding a new layer of complexity and intrigue.

Banana peppers can almost match bell peppers cup for cup, but don’t be discouraged from adding a few extra if your dish demands. They’re best enjoyed with cheeses or in vinaigrettes, where their mellow sweetness adds an engaging layer without overpowering the palate.

5 – Jalapeño Peppers

If you’re in the mood for some spice, consider jalapeños as a fiery alternative to bell peppers. Originating from Mexico and known for their distinct heat, jalapeños pack a punch that can elevate dishes like nacho cheese dips and frittatas.

Don’t let their spiciness intimidate you – jalapeños have a unique flavor profile that’s worth exploring. When roasted, they offer a smoky and slightly sweet undertone that balances out their heat.

It’s best to tread with caution when substituting for jalapeños – their fiery nature can quickly overpower a dish if not used in moderation. Start with a small amount and taste as you go, adjusting the heat level to your liking. And don’t forget to wear gloves while handling them! Trust us on this one.


So there you have it – five delicious and versatile substitutes for bell peppers that will elevate your dishes and bring a new dimension of flavor to your meals.

Keep these substitutes in mind next time you find yourself without bell peppers, and you’ll never have to compromise on taste and quality in the kitchen.