Skip to Content

4 Substitutes for Rum Extract to Consider

Want a rum extract substitute that won’t leave you hanging? We’ve got your back. Whether you’re baking cookies, whipping up a cake, or crafting the ultimate cocktail, missing that key ingredient can be a bummer.

Good news — there are some simple swaps that save the day. Have you tried vanilla extract? Adds a smooth, sweet twist. Almond extract? A bit nutty, in a good way. How about dark rum or even maple syrup?

Yes, really. These swaps can give your dish the flavor punch it needs. We get it, running out of an ingredient mid-recipe is the worst. Let’s get this flavor party started!

4 Easy Substitutes for Rum Extract

As promised, here are some easy substitutes to keep baking and mixing those drinks, worry-free.

1 – Rum Flavoring

Alright, let’s talk rum flavoring. This substitute is our top choice for that classic rum taste. Why?

We love it because it truly mimics the depth of real rum. Compared to actual rum, rum flavoring has a slightly sweeter undertone.

It’s perfect for eliminating the alcohol while keeping the essence. Mixing it into our baked goods gives us that rich, aromatic profile.

We tried it in cake batter, and it was like biting into a tropical treat. Easy to use, reliable, and oh so flavorful.

2 – Brandy

The brandy flavor is distinct and robust. It’s a tad sweeter than rum but keeps that rich, warm essence. We’ve tried it in cookies, and they tasted like a holiday feast.

The depth it adds is undeniable, making it perfect for both baking and drinks. Curious for more brandy swaps? Check out this guide to brandy substitutes.

We love how it balances the flavors. It might not have the exact boozy kick, but it sure makes up for it with its fragrant depth. Fun fact: it’s an MVP in cakes.

3 – Vanilla Extract

The vanilla extract brings a sweet, aromatic note that’s unmistakable. It’s versatile and blends seamlessly in many recipes.

The flavor is smooth with a hint of creaminess. We’ve added it to cakes, and wow, the result was rich and comforting.

It’s slightly less bold than rum but incredibly reliable. The taste profile is more subtle, yet it complements other ingredients well.

Looking for more variations? Check out our guide to vanilla extract substitutes.

4 – Spiced Apple Cider

Spiced apple cider brings a cozy, warm flavor to any recipe. It’s sweet and slightly tangy, with a cinnamon kick that screams comfort. We stirred it into muffin batter and got a festive twist.

The hint of spices adds depth, making it a close competitor to rum. We love using it around the holidays for that extra festive feel. Its complex profile does wonders in baked goods and beverages.

With spiced apple cider, you get a natural sweetness, plus a spicy fragrance that lifts the dish. It’s a simple, effective swap we can get behind.