Skip to Content

6 Easy Marmite Substitutes: Jazz Up the Recipes

Who knew Marmite had a posse of substitutes? We did. Sometimes, you reach for that jar and realize it’s empty. No problem.

We’ve got your back with six easy replacements that can jazz up your recipes just as well. Marmite lovers, meet your new best friends.

From the smooth and salty to the tangy and bold, these options will keep your taste buds guessing and your meals exciting. Trust us, you won’t miss a beat in the kitchen.

We’ve tested them all, and some might surprise you. So, ready to mix things up? Let’s get started!

6 Easy Substitutes for Marmite

For those who may not be familiar, Marmite is a popular British spread made from yeast extract. It has a very distinct and strong flavor that people either love or hate. If you fall into the “love” category but can’t seem to find it at your local store, don’t worry! These substitutes will satisfy your cravings just as well.

1 – Vegemite

The next Marmite stand-in is Vegemite, and it’s a solid choice. Taste-wise, Vegemite is intense, salty, and has that umami punch we love. It’s got a similar bold flavor, but some say it’s a bit smoother and richer.

We’ve tasted both, and Vegemite brings a slightly different but equally satisfying experience. If you enjoy Marmite, you’ll probably take a quick liking to Vegemite. Check out this article on Vegemite substitutes for more options.

Overall, Vegemite is a great Marmite alternative, keeping breakfast, snacks, and recipes just as tasty.

2 – Promite

Next, let’s talk Promite. This one’s another yeast-extract spread, super popular down under. We’ve given it a whirl, and here’s what stood out.

Promite has a milder taste compared to Marmite and Vegemite. Still salty, sure, but not as in-your-face. It’s sweeter too, thanks to the addition of sugar. We found it smoother, a bit like spreading butter. Perfect for those morning toasts or midnight snacks.

Texture? Spot on. Think more velvety, less gritty. It’s easy to spread. For those who find Marmite too intense, Promite is your go-to.

3 – Miso Paste

When it comes to versatile spreads, miso paste is a top contender. This Japanese staple isn’t just for soup. We’ve tried it, and it’s a game changer for your toast.

The flavor? Uber savory. It brings that same umami kick as Marmite but with a twist. Miso is less salty, slightly sweet, and a bit earthy.

We found it perfect for balancing out recipes. Plus, it spreads like a dream. If you’re curious, check out our guide on miso substitutes for more variety. Give miso a go; it won’t disappoint.

4 – Nutritional Yeast

The hidden gem of vegan diets is nutritional yeast. This stuff is all about that cheesy, nutty flavor. It’s a bit like parmesan, but with a twist. Sprinkle it on popcorn, mix it into sauces, or use it as a spread – versatile is its middle name.

We tried it on toast; man, it did not disappoint. Nutritional yeast is not as salty as Marmite, but packs an umami punch that’s spot on. It’s a bit mild, so you might need a little extra sprinkle to get that full flavor. Interested in more uses? Check out our guide on nutritional yeast substitutes. It’s chock-full of ideas.

5 – Soy Sauce

One of the easiest substitutes is soy sauce. Soy sauce is savory, salty, and full of umami goodness. We use it in a lot of dishes, and it works great on toast too.

Flavor-wise, soy sauce is a bit brinier compared to Marmite. It offers a deeper, more complex taste. We found that a little goes a long way. To get that Marmite-like experience, just use a few drops.

Looking for more options? Check out our list of soy sauce substitutes. Soy sauce might surprise you with its versatility and depth, making it an excellent Marmite alternative.

6 – Bovril

There is something special about Bovril. It’s got that beefy essence Marmite fans might love. Let’s talk flavor: Bovril is rich, meaty, and oh so hearty. It’s like drinking a warm beef stew in spread form.

Bovril spreads easily on toast, just how we like it. We find it comforting, like a cozy blanket on a chilly day. Perfect for those who want a Marmite substitute that’s equally robust.

Personal tip? Try mixing Bovril with butter for a savory, smooth treat. It’s a simple hack that elevates any snack. So, ready to give Bovril a go?