Skip to Content

5 Great Substitutes for Amaro Averna: Elevate the Cocktails

Amaro Averna turns a good cocktail into a great one. That’s a fact.

We’ve all been there. The bottle’s empty and our favorites store is closed. What do we do? Panic? Nope.

We get creative. Lucky for us, we’ve found some killer substitutes.

It’s story time! Last summer, mid-party, we ran out. The mood? About to crash. Then, innovation struck. We tried something new and guess what? It was a hit.

Ready to shake things up? Here we go!

5 Great Substitutes for Amaro Averna

Without further ado, here are five alternatives to Amaro Averna that will take your cocktails to the next level:

1 – Cynar

Cynar is the underdog of cocktail ingredients. Think of it as Amaro Averna’s quirky cousin. It’s artichoke-based. Yes, you heard right, artichokes. But hey, don’t knock it till you’ve tried it. This stuff brings a unique, bittersweet punch to the party.

It’s less sweet and more herbaceous. Perfect for stirring up something new and exciting. We once swapped in Cynar on a whim during a cocktail experiment night. Guests were baffled but totally into it.

For those of you eager to mix it up even more, peep this guide we stumbled upon. It’s got everything you need for when you’re looking to twist things up a notch with your drinks.

2 – Fernet-Branca

Fernet-Branca is a whole different beast. It’s like the wild card of your bar. Bold and aromatic, its minty notes can flip any cocktail on its head.

We tossed it into a mix last Friday. Raised eyebrows all around. This one’s for the brave. It’s not shy. It makes a statement.

In our circles, it’s now a legend. One sip, and you’re hooked or you’re out. Crafting with Fernet? Keep it simple. It stands tall on its own.

Balance is key. Too much, and it’s overpowering. Just right, and it’s a game-changer.

We learned that the hard way. One wild night, too much Fernet. Lessons were learned.

In short, Fernet-Branca. Not for the faint-hearted. Mix with caution, enjoy with gusto.

3 – Amaro Montenegro

Amaro Montenegro is the light at the end of the tunnel for those missing Amaro Averna. It’s citrusy, sweet, yet complex. The perfect partner in crime for any cocktail needing a twist. We’ve tried it. Love at first sip.

It’s lighter than Amaro Averna. Our go-to for a more refreshing, summer vibe drink. We remember mixing it into a spritz. Our friends asked for seconds. Then thirds.

Craft cocktails with it? Absolutely. Expect a smoother ride, with a gentler kick at the end. A crowd-pleaser, for sure.

4 – Ramazzotti

Ramazzotti might just become your new best friend. It’s as versatile as a Swiss Army knife. We’ve thrown it into everything from highballs to martinis. It’s got that rich, caramel depth with a kick of spices that lights up your drink.

Our first encounter? A party saver. We mixed it into a batch of emergency Manhattans. The crowd was mystified, thrilled even.

Its secret sauce? A blend of herbs and orange peel. Not too sweet, not too bitter. Just right. Perfect for those looking for a middle ground.

We say, give it a go. Ramazzotti doesn’t just fill shoes; it dances in them. Your bar will thank us.

5 – Cardamaro

Cardamaro is a game-changer. It’s the MVP of your drink list.

It packs a vino amaro punch, blending wine with cardoon and blessed thistle.

It’s not your regular Joe. This stuff is unique. We’ve used it in everything from negronis to whiskey sours.

Its vibe? Warm, herbal, with a hint of spice. Perfect for chilly nights.

Our friends were itching for the recipe. Cardamaro steps up. Elevates the cocktail scene.

Bold, yet understated. It makes every sip an experience. We swear by it. Your bar needs this.

It’s the secret you didn’t know you were missing.