Skip to Content

6 Tasty Basket Cheese Substitutes: Amp Up the Flavor

Basket cheese? That’s something we all need to talk about. You see, basket cheese is like that underrated guy in a band who holds everything together but doesn’t always get the spotlight.

We’ve all had that moment at a gathering where a dish just pops because of the cheese in it. Sometimes it can be basket cheese doing the heavy lifting. This cheese adds that perfect mild, creamy texture we crave.

And yes, it’s good enough to steal the show. Whether you put it in salads, sandwiches, or even just snack on it as is, basket cheese is worth knowing more about.

6 Easy Substitutes for Basket Cheese

For those who are looking to spice things up and try something new, here are six tasty substitutes for basket cheese that will amp up the flavor of your dishes:

SubstituteTasteTextureRatioSuitable Dishes
Ricotta CheeseMild, CreamySoft1:1Lasagna, Stuffed Shells
Feta CheeseTangy, SaltyCrumbly1:1Salads, Pastries, Pizzas
Queso FrescoMild, FreshCrumbly1:1Tacos, Salads, Tamales
Halloumi CheeseSalty, ChewyFirm1:1Grilled Cheese, Salads
Paneer CheeseMild, FirmFirm1:1Curries, Stir-fries, Kebabs
Cottage CheeseMild, CreamySoft1:1Pancakes, Cheesecakes, Dips

1 – Ricotta Cheese

Ricotta is a superstar. It’s creamy and smooth, making it perfect for countless recipes. We love it because it’s versatile and easy to use.

Ricotta works one-to-one as a substitute for basket cheese. Mix it in your dish, and voilà! It’s excellent in lasagna, stuffed shells, and even on toast.

We tried it out in our favorite pasta salad, and it did not disappoint. Its texture and mild taste fit right in. Curious about other swaps for ricotta? Check out this handy guide for more ideas.

2 – Feta Cheese

Okay, feta! You spot this crumbly goodness in salads and wraps. It’s sharper and saltier than basket cheese, making it a standout. Not only does it add zing, but it also crumbles beautifully into any dish. Got a Greek salad? Feta’s your buddy.

Don’t underestimate the power of this cheese in cooked dishes too. Use it in a 1:1 ratio with basket cheese for that tangy kick. We swapped it in our quiche, and goodness, it was an upgrade!

Check out our guide on even more feta cheese substitutes. You won’t regret exploring your options!

3 – Queso Fresco

You ever tried queso fresco? It’s like the cool, lesser-known cousin of feta. Picture it: mild, slightly salty, and crumbly goodness. It’s got a fresh, milky flavor that works magic in almost anything.

We love using queso fresco as a basket cheese substitute, especially in heated dishes. Trust us, it melts nicely. Try it in enchiladas, it’s a hit!

The ratio is easy: use it 1:1 with basket cheese. Need more ideas on using queso fresco? Check this guide on queso fresco substitutes. You’ll thank us later.

4 – Halloumi Cheese

Halloumi is the cheese that can handle the heat. You can grill, fry, or even bake it without it melting all over the place. It’s got a firm, chewy texture that we love.

It’s slightly salty and brings a new dimension to salads, sandwiches, and grilled dishes. Replace basket cheese with halloumi at a 1:1 ratio. We tried it in our grilled veggie wrap, and it was a total success.

Got extra halloumi? Check out these halloumi cheese substitutes to keep your dishes fresh.

5 – Paneer Cheese

Paneer is the cheese that surprised us the most. It’s firm and holds up well in high-heat dishes. It doesn’t melt, so it’s perfect for grilling or frying.

We love its mild, milk-like flavor. It’s subtle but adds creaminess to your recipes. Use paneer as a 1:1 substitute for basket cheese.

Tired of the usual cheeses? Give paneer a shot in your curries or wraps. Need more swap ideas? Check out our paneer cheese substitutes for more options. It’s versatile and great in almost anything.

6 – Cottage Cheese

Last but certainly not least, cottage cheese! Yes, it works as a basket cheese substitute. It’s creamy and has a mild taste that blends in with your dishes.

We recommend using cottage cheese as a 1:1 ratio swap. Its texture is similar to basket cheese, so you won’t lose out on any creaminess.