• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Recipe Index
  • Substitutes
  • Side Dishes
  • Dinner
  • Desserts
  • About Us

CooksCrafter

menu icon
go to homepage
  • Recipe Index
  • Substitutes
  • Side Dishes
  • Dinner
  • Desserts
  • About Us
subscribe
search icon
Homepage link
  • Recipe Index
  • Substitutes
  • Side Dishes
  • Dinner
  • Desserts
  • About Us
×
Home » Cooking » Substitutes

Latest Updated: Nov 16, 2026 by Andrew Gray

5 Best Caraway Seed Substitutes for Rye Bread, Sauerkraut and Stews

Short Answer

The best substitute for caraway seeds is dill seed, used teaspoon for teaspoon, because both seeds hold carvone as their main aroma compound.

  • For rye bread and sauerkraut, use dill seed or ¾ teaspoon of fennel seed for each teaspoon of caraway.
  • For goulash and other meat stews, use ½ teaspoon of cumin seed per teaspoon, because cumin adds earthy warmth with no licorice taste.
  • No source gives a caraway swap ratio, so every amount here is a starting amount to taste and adjust.
Three ramekins of dill, fennel and cumin seed beside a sliced dark rye loaf - caraway seed substitutes | CooksCrafter Save for Later!

Caraway seed gives rye bread, sauerkraut and slow-cooked beef or pork a warm, slightly sweet aroma with a licorice edge, and that aroma is the part a stand-in has to match. Among the spice swaps you can make, caraway needs three different stand-ins: dill seed for rye and sauerkraut, fennel seed for a sweetened dough, and cumin seed for a meat stew.

Table of Contents

Toggle
  • 1 What Does Caraway Seed Do in a Recipe?
  • 2 Best Substitutes for Caraway Seeds
    • Dill Seed
    • Fennel Seed
    • Cumin Seed
    • Anise Seed
    • Nigella Seed
  • 3 How Do You Add a Substitute Seed to the Dish?
  • 4 Which Substitute Fits Rye Bread, Sauerkraut and Stews?
  • 5 Which Seeds Do Not Replace Caraway?
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Sources

1 What Does Caraway Seed Do in a Recipe?

Caraway seeds are the dried fruit of Carum carvi, and the oil that makes them smell the way they do is mostly two compounds. A 2019 review notes that the European Pharmacopoeia expects 50 to 65% d-carvone and up to 45% limonene in that oil, and d-carvone is the compound behind the smell people call caraway.

Sliced dark rye loaf with seeds in the crumb on a wooden board - caraway seeds | CooksCrafter Save for Later!
Whole seeds in a rye crumb give the aroma a stand-in has to match.

Caraway fruits are used to flavor rye bread, and in sauerkraut and stews the seeds soften in the liquid and give it their aroma. A stand-in therefore has to hold up through a long bake or a long simmer.

In one Turkish study of seed oils, dill seed oil was 67.41% carvone and 30.58% limonene, the same two compounds that lead in caraway, so dill seed is the closest match, since carvone leads dill seed oil. Fennel and anise lean on a different compound, anethole, and cumin on cuminaldehyde, which is why they taste like another spice even when the swap works.

2 Best Substitutes for Caraway Seeds

No source publishes a swap ratio for caraway, so each amount is this site's own starting amount per 1 teaspoon of caraway seed. Add it, taste, and raise it a pinch at a time.

SubstituteAmount per 1 teaspoon carawayBest forWhat changes
Dill seed1 teaspoonRye bread, sauerkraut, potatoesClosest flavor, with a fresh dill note
Fennel seed¾ teaspoonSweetened rye dough, cabbage with onion or appleSweeter, with a licorice taste
Cumin seed½ teaspoonGoulash, beef and pork stewsEarthy and warm, with no licorice
Anise seed½ teaspoonSweet rye rolls, cabbage with applesStrong licorice flavor
Nigella seed½ teaspoonTopping on rolls and flatbreadPeppery, with no caraway flavor

Dill seed and fennel seed fit breads and cabbage, cumin seed fits meat stews, and anise and nigella are last picks for most dishes.

Dill Seed

Dill seed (Anethum graveolens) is the nearest match, so you can use 1 teaspoon for each teaspoon of caraway, whole for whole and ground for ground. It fits rye dough, sauerkraut and potato dishes, and it leaves a fresh dill note that is easy to spot in a sweet loaf.

You want the jar labeled dill seed. Dill weed is the feathery leaf of the same plant, sold as a herb, so it is the wrong jar for this swap.

Fennel Seed

Fennel seed (Foeniculum vulgare) brings sweetness and a licorice taste, because its oil was 88.79% anethole in that same Turkish sample. Start with ¾ teaspoon per teaspoon of caraway, since the licorice note is stronger than caraway's. You will like it in a sweetened rye dough and in cabbage cooked with onion or apple, and you will find it out of place in a beef and paprika stew.

Tip

A dough hides its flavor until the loaf is baked, so keep every swap at the table amount for bread and raise it only in the next batch.

Cumin Seed

Cumin seed (Cuminum cyminum) belongs to the same plant family as dill, fennel and anise, yet in that same Turkish sample its oil was led by cuminaldehyde (32.13%), gamma-terpinene and beta-pinene, with no carvone or anethole among the main compounds. Use ½ teaspoon per teaspoon of caraway in beef, pork and bean stews, where your pot needs earthy warmth more than sweetness.

Start at half because cumin brings an earthy flavor that caraway does not have, and a pinch is easier to add to a pot than to take out. Treat the half teaspoon as your own starting amount and raise it a pinch at a time.

A Hungarian goulash that serves six uses 1 teaspoon of caraway seeds, so the swap is just ½ teaspoon of cumin seed for the whole pot. In your rye bread or sauerkraut, cumin will read as a different spice, because it has none of caraway's sweetness.

Anise Seed

Anise seed (Pimpinella anisum) is almost pure licorice flavor, since its oil was 93.74% anethole in that Turkish sample, with little else beside it. Use ½ teaspoon per teaspoon of caraway in sweet rye rolls or braised cabbage with apples, and skip it when you make a savory beef stew.

Nigella Seed

Nigella seed (Nigella sativa) is sold as black cumin, but it belongs to the buttercup family, and a 2014 analysis of seeds bought in India found thymoquinone (37.6%) and p-cymene as the leading compounds in the oil. Use ½ teaspoon per teaspoon of caraway inside food.

  • On rolls or flatbread, you scatter nigella over the top, where it gives the same speckled look as caraway.
  • In dough, sauerkraut or stew, keep it to the starting amount, because its peppery flavor is nothing like caraway's.

3 How Do You Add a Substitute Seed to the Dish?

A swap seed acts most like caraway when it goes in at the same moment and in the same form.

  1. Measure before you grind. Level the table amount from whole seeds, then grind it in a mortar if your recipe lists ground caraway.
  2. Warm the seeds. Dry-toast fennel, cumin or anise seeds in a skillet over medium-low heat until they smell warm and turn a shade darker, then tip them out so they stop cooking.
  3. Add them where caraway goes. Mix the seeds into rye dough with the flour, stir them into cabbage when you pack or cook it, and stir them in with the paprika when you build a stew, the way the goulash above adds its caraway.
  4. Taste, then top up. Taste the kraut or stew after it has simmered a few minutes, and add a pinch at a time.

Small dry seeds scorch fast, so keep the pan moving and pull it off the heat as soon as you smell the change.

Fennel seeds toasting in a dry cast iron skillet on a stovetop - caraway seed substitute | CooksCrafter Save for Later!
Fennel seeds in a dry skillet come off the heat once they turn a shade darker.

4 Which Substitute Fits Rye Bread, Sauerkraut and Stews?

Pick dill seed for savory rye, sauerkraut and potatoes, where its fresh note fits, and fennel seed when the dish is already sweet, such as a sweetened dough or cabbage with apple or onion, because fennel adds sweetness of its own.

Dill Seed

Matches caraway's carvone aroma at 1 teaspoon per teaspoon.

Leaves a fresh dill note that shows up in a sweet loaf.

Fennel Seed

Adds sweetness that suits rye dough and cabbage cooked with onion or apple.

Its licorice taste is stronger, so it goes in at ¾ teaspoon and still tastes different.

Your meat stew goes to cumin seed instead, because the pot is built on beef, onions and paprika, and cumin goes with all three.

Bowl of paprika-red beef stew with potatoes and carrots beside a slice of crusty bread - goulash | CooksCrafter Save for Later!
A paprika-red beef stew is where ½ teaspoon of cumin seed per teaspoon of caraway fits.
  • Rye bread and rolls take dill seed first, or fennel seed when the dough is sweetened.
  • Sauerkraut takes dill seed or fennel seed stirred in with the cabbage, and sauerkraut warmed in a skillet is a standard side on a plate of bratwurst, where fennel seed stirred in with the cabbage is the swap above.
  • Goulash and other beef or pork stews take cumin seed, stirred in with the paprika.
  • Potato dishes take dill seed at the table amount, and you can also leave the seed out, as a potato salad with optional caraway does.

5 Which Seeds Do Not Replace Caraway?

Three seeds sit near caraway on many spice racks, and none of them replaces it.

  • Coriander seed was 98.96% linalool in the Turkish study, with no carvone, so rye and sauerkraut lose the caraway aroma entirely.
  • Carom seed, also sold as ajwain (Trachyspermum ammi), comes from a different plant, so it is not a caraway stand-in.
  • Fenugreek seed (Trigonella foenum-graecum) is a bitter legume seed, so it adds bitterness where caraway adds warmth.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you leave caraway seeds out of a recipe?

Yes. Rye bread still rises and the kraut or stew still cooks, and the dish only loses the carvone aroma. Leave the seed out when nothing in your cupboard fits the dish.

Can you mix two seeds instead of using one?

Yes. Use ½ teaspoon of dill seed plus ¼ teaspoon of fennel seed for each teaspoon of caraway. This is the page's own starting amount, so taste and adjust.

Should the swap seed be whole or ground?

Whole seeds replace whole caraway and ground seeds replace ground caraway, which is how the dill amount is stated above. For fennel, cumin and anise, level the table amount from whole seeds first, and grind it only when your recipe lists ground caraway. Taste, then adjust.

Sources

  • Chemical composition and biological activities of essential oils of seven cultivated Apiaceae species, Scientific Reports, 2024.
  • Caraway as Important Medicinal Plants in Management of Diseases, Natural Products and Bioprospecting, 2019.
  • Composition, in vitro antioxidant and antimicrobial activities of essential oil and oleoresins obtained from black cumin seeds (Nigella sativa L.), BioMed Research International, 2014.
Andrew Gray - CooksCrafter founder
Andrew Gray

Andrew Gray is a seasoned food writer and blogger with a wealth of experience in the restaurant and catering industries. With a passion for all things delicious, Andrew has honed his culinary expertise through his work as a personal chef and caterer.

His love for food led him to venture into food writing, where he has contributed to various online publications, sharing his knowledge and insights on the culinary world. As the proud owner of CooksCrafter.com, Andrew covers a wide range of topics, including recipes, restaurant reviews, product recommendations, and culinary tips.

Through his website, he aims to inspire and educate fellow food enthusiasts, offering a comprehensive resource for all things food-related.

More Substitutes

  • Monterey Jack, Colby Jack, Muenster and mild cheddar cut on a wooden board - Monterey Jack cheese substitutes | CooksCrafter
    7 Best Monterey Jack Cheese Substitutes for Melting
  • Three bowls of different flours on a wooden table - flour substitutes for baking | CooksCrafter
    7 Best Flour Substitutes for Baking When You Are Out of Flour
  • Small bowls of chopped walnuts, pecans, almonds, hazelnuts and pumpkin seeds - walnut substitutes | CooksCrafter
    7 Best Walnut Substitutes for Baking and Salads
  • Bowls of sunflower seeds, pumpkin seeds, oats, coconut and pretzel pieces - substitutes for nuts in baking | CooksCrafter
    7 Best Substitutes for Nuts in Baking With Ratios

Primary Sidebar

Andrew Gray - CooksCrafter founder

Hey, I'm Andrew!

Founder & Head of Content

14 years in professional kitchens. Now I help home cooks skip the guesswork with clear substitutes, smart shortcuts, and recipes that actually work.

My Story →

Trending Now

  • Three ramekins of dill, fennel and cumin seed beside a sliced dark rye loaf - caraway seed substitutes | CooksCrafter
    5 Best Caraway Seed Substitutes for Rye Bread, Sauerkraut and Stews
  • Pan-fried gyoza with a soy and chili dipping sauce - what to serve with gyoza | CooksCrafter
    What to Serve with Gyoza: 12 Side Dishes
  • Spiralized Cucumber and Avocado Salad - feature
    Spiralized Cucumber and Avocado Salad
  • Roasted Sweet Potato and Pomegranate Salad - feature
    Roasted Sweet Potato and Pomegranate Salad

Free Email Tips

Cook Smarter

Join the email list for ingredient swaps, quick recipes, and kitchen shortcuts.

Subscribe Free →

Seasonal Picks

  • 20 quick and nourishing vegan dinner rec l7aBS9mGSrKXTriAAyE2kw fc2d2LTeQTObmhYXFwpCRA
    20 Quick Nourishing Vegan Dinner Recipes
  • 20 no oven dinner recipes to keep you co jNr3DSYLQy2oXFIWDwfYXA XwcIP4leRqquJhHrsxw2Ig
    20 No-Oven Dinner Recipes to Keep You Cool and Satisfied
  • Class food dinners meal b0iTLY70RauiD3fSsH5A4Q j2 uOpbmS1mqmLkRGwSvYg
    20 Classic Comfort Food Dinners Made Easy
  • Low carb dinner recipes for flavorful an 4GQncc6tQYSpxhkhJHi15Q V8OskMFpSmGmqR236GVvhg
    20 Low-Carb Dinners That Still Feel Like a Treat

Browse by Topic

  • Ingredient Substitutes
  • Side Dishes
  • Dinner Recipes
  • Air Fryer
  • Salads
  • Desserts

Footer

CooksCrafter

Ingredient swaps with ratios, side dish pairings and dinner ideas for home cooks in the United States.

We check food safety and storage numbers against USDA FSIS, USDA FoodKeeper and FDA guidance each time we update a guide.

Explore

  • Ingredient Substitutes
  • Side Dishes
  • Dinner
  • Air Fryer
  • Salads
  • Desserts
  • Recipe Index

Popular Guides

  • Plain vs All-Purpose Flour
  • Parmesan Substitutes
  • Pork Loin Roast Recipes
  • Greek Yogurt Sauces
  • Award-Winning Chili
  • Air Fryer Flounder

About

  • About Us
  • Andrew Gray, Editor
  • Contact and Corrections
  • Newsletter

Policies

  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclosure
  • Terms of Service

© 2026 CooksCrafter. All rights reserved.

↑ Back to top