Short Answer
The best side dishes for tomato pie are garlic butter shrimp, lemon herb roasted chicken and a crisp side such as balsamic green beans or an arugula and pear salad.
- Tomato pie has a rich mayonnaise-and-cheese topping and no protein.
- The plate needs a protein and something sharp or crunchy.
Southern tomato pie is a baked pie crust filled with salted tomato slices and basil, then covered with melted mayonnaise and cheese. It has crust, cheese and tomato but no meat, so add a protein and something crisp and leave a second bread off the plate. Trenton-style tomato pie, a thin pizza-style crust with the sauce on top, is a different dish.
1 What Goes Well with Tomato Pie?
The mayonnaise-and-cheese topping browns into a rich layer over soft tomatoes, so the plate needs sharp, crisp and savory sides. Lemon, vinegar and peppery greens cut through the topping, while fried or grilled food adds the bite that the filling lacks.
If you let the baked pie rest before you slice it, the tomato juices thicken as the pie cools, and the wedge holds together on the plate. It tastes good warm or at room temperature, which gives you time to cook the sides.
Southern tables serve tomato pie in summer with Southern-style sides such as fried okra and corn pudding.
| Side | Role | What it adds to the pie |
|---|---|---|
| Garlic Butter Shrimp | Protein | Garlic and lemon against the rich topping |
| Lemon Herb Roasted Chicken | Protein | A whole bird for a crowd, with lemon and herbs |
| Thin Pork Chops | Protein | A savory, paprika-seasoned crust |
| Balsamic Glazed Green Beans | Crisp vegetable | Snap and a sweet-sharp glaze |
| Fried Okra | Crisp vegetable | A crunchy coating against soft tomato |
| Grilled Corn on the Cob | Charred vegetable | Sweet, smoky kernels |
| Roasted Zucchini | Vegetable | Browned edges and a mild flavor |
| Arugula and Pear Salad | Cold salad | Peppery leaves and sweet pear |
| Pickled Cucumber and Radish Salad | Cold salad | A chilled vinegar bite |
| Parmesan Roasted Potatoes | Starch | Crisp edges for a hungry crowd |
Tomato pie has no protein, so a dinner plate adds one and a lunch plate can skip it.
Tomato Pie for Dinner
Shrimp, chicken or thin pork chops add the protein the pie lacks, and a crisp vegetable such as green beans or okra keeps the plate from turning soft.
The protein needs the stove or oven while the pie rests, so cook one protein and let the rest of the plate stay simple.
Tomato Pie for Lunch
A peppery arugula and pear salad or a chilled pickled cucumber and radish salad adds the sharp contrast, and every part can sit at room temperature.
With no protein, the plate is vegetarian and fills fewer hungry eaters than the dinner plate.
2 Which Proteins Go with Tomato Pie?
Tomato pie has cheese but no meat or fish, so a protein turns a slice into dinner. Shrimp, chicken and thin chops all suit it, and one of them is enough for a family meal.
1. Garlic Butter Shrimp
Garlic and lemon in the pan sauce give the sharpness that the topping needs. Shrimp cook in a few minutes, so cook them last, while you slice the pie, and take them off the heat as soon as the flesh turns opaque, because they turn rubbery if they keep cooking.
Full recipe: Garlic Butter Shrimp from Dinner at the Zoo
2. Lemon Herb Roasted Chicken
A whole roast chicken feeds a crowd, and its lemon and herbs echo the basil in the pie. The pie and the chicken both want the oven, so bake the pie first and roast the chicken while the pie cools to room temperature. Carve the chicken after it rests, so the juices stay in the meat instead of running onto the plate.
Full recipe: Lemon and Herb Roasted Chicken from Minimalist Baker
3. Thin Pork Chops
Thin boneless chops cook quickly, because thin chops in the air fryer finish in 10 minutes at 400°F. If you season them with paprika and garlic powder, they give the plate a savory crust that the soft pie does not have.
Food Safety
The USDA says to cook chicken to 165°F and pork chops to at least 145°F, with a 3-minute rest for the chops, measured with a food thermometer in the thickest part.
3 Which Vegetables Add Crunch?
The tomatoes in the pie are soft, so a vegetable with snap or browned edges gives your plate its texture.
4. Balsamic Glazed Green Beans
If you cook the beans until crisp-tender, they keep their snap, and the glaze adds a sweet, sharp note that the pie does not have. Balsamic glaze is balsamic vinegar reduced with honey, and if you are out of the vinegar, a balsamic vinegar swap such as red wine vinegar with honey keeps the same sweet-sharp balance.
Full recipe: Balsamic Glazed Green Beans from Heinen's Grocery Store
5. Fried Okra
Okra and tomatoes already share Southern plates, and a cornmeal coating fried until golden gives the crunch that soft tomato slices lack. Drain the pieces on a rack instead of a flat plate, so steam does not soften the coating from underneath.
Full recipe: Southern Fried Okra from Spicy Southern Kitchen
6. Grilled Corn on the Cob
Grilled corn has sweet, charred kernels that stand up to the cheese topping, and if you add a squeeze of lime and a pinch of chili powder, you give the plate the acid the pie lacks. If the grill is not lit, corn in the Instant Pot cooks husked ears in 2 minutes at high pressure.
Full recipe: Grilled Corn on the Cob from Spend with Pennies
7. Roasted Zucchini
Zucchini is mild enough not to compete with the pie, and a squeeze of lemon adds the sharp edge.
Tip
Zucchini holds a lot of water, so spread the slices in one layer with space between them, and they brown instead of steaming.
Full recipe: Roasted Zucchini from Love and Lemons
4 Which Salads and Starches Fit Tomato Pie?
A cold salad gives the warm pie a sharp contrast, and you only need a starch when you feed a crowd.
8. Arugula and Pear Salad
Peppery arugula and sweet pear cut through the mayonnaise-and-cheese topping, and a honey-balsamic dressing at about 3 parts oil to 1 part vinegar ties them together. Because the pie is already cheesy, crumble only a little goat cheese and let the toasted walnuts or pecans give the crunch. Toast the walnuts or pecans in a dry skillet while you whisk the dressing for this arugula and pear salad.
9. Pickled Cucumber and Radish Salad
Rice vinegar brine gives this salad the clean, sharp bite that a creamy topping needs, and the thin slices stay cold and crisp. Rice vinegar and 30 minutes in the fridge are all the quick-pickled cucumbers and radishes need, and the slices keep their snap.
10. Parmesan Roasted Potatoes
The pie crust already counts as the starch, so potatoes suit a bigger crowd or hungrier eaters better than a light dinner. If you roast them until the Parmesan crust browns, you get crisp edges around a soft center, which gives the plate texture the pie does not have.
Full recipe: Crispy Parmesan Roasted Potatoes from Ambitious Kitchen
5 Which Sides Should You Skip with Tomato Pie?
These pairings crowd a pie that is already crust, creamy topping and tomato:
- Buttermilk biscuits and savory bread pudding. The pie has a crust, and a second bread leaves the plate all pastry. Biscuits fit only when a small wedge of pie is one dish on a brunch table.
- Caprese quinoa salad. Tomatoes and basil appear twice on the plate. It suits a summer buffet where the pie is not served.
- Caesar salad and creamy cucumber dill salad. A creamy dressing next to the mayonnaise-and-cheese topping makes everything rich. They fit beside a plain main without a creamy topping.
6 When Do You Bake the Pie and Cook the Sides?
Because the pie needs the oven first, you bake it early and cook the protein last.
- Start the cucumber salad. It needs at least 30 minutes in the fridge, so make it before anything else.
- Bake the pie. It needs time to rest and set before you slice it, and it tastes good warm or at room temperature.
- Roast the oven sides. The chicken, potatoes or zucchini go in once the pie leaves the oven.
- Cook the shrimp or chops, and dress the arugula. Both take only minutes, so do them while you slice the pie.
Sources

Andrew Gray is a seasoned food writer and blogger with a wealth of experience in the restaurant and catering industries. With a passion for all things delicious, Andrew has honed his culinary expertise through his work as a personal chef and caterer.
His love for food led him to venture into food writing, where he has contributed to various online publications, sharing his knowledge and insights on the culinary world. As the proud owner of CooksCrafter.com, Andrew covers a wide range of topics, including recipes, restaurant reviews, product recommendations, and culinary tips.
Through his website, he aims to inspire and educate fellow food enthusiasts, offering a comprehensive resource for all things food-related.








